John Deere gas tractor
What FARM SHOW readers say · 46 Best Buys5 Worst Buys · Tractors
John Deere gas tractor
46 Best Buys5 Worst Buys“One of my best buys has been my 1973 Deere 2030 gas tractor, which I bought used 20 years ago. It also has a Westendorf loader, another best buy. It’s a very handy outfit that gets a lot of use on my small farm.”
“My Ford 8N was a best buy despite a couple of limitations. It didn’t have live power and was only a 5-speed transmission, so stopping power and speed were limited. I sold it to purchase a Deere 2010 tractor with live power. With live power, the mower can be engaged or disengaged safely with little effort. My wife and 11-year-old granddaughter can now mow our driveway and road ditches with a brush hog mower easily and safely. Another feature is the Deere has eight forward speeds and three reverse. Plus, my granddaughter says, ‘It’s a cool looking John Deere.’
“On a recommendation from a relative, I purchased a new Husqvarna chainsaw. Hands down, it became my worst purchase ever. On the first tank of gas, the piston tore up the motor, and we couldn’t find parts. The dealer told us that because it was a closeout, he couldn’t honor the warranty, and a boat anchor was created. When I called, the company wouldn’t even listen to my problem. Thank goodness I have several newer and old Stihl chainsaws to save the day.”
I had 20 Deere tractors. They were all great with no problems.”
“My 2021 Ford F-250 pickup is good on fuel. The warranty was honored.
“It’s hard to get parts for my 2011 Deere lawn tractor.”
“Both my Scag zero-turn lawn mower and Gravely ATV do a good job and I’ve had no trouble with either. We usually mow three acres or more twice a week.
“I also have several 2-cyl. Deere tractors and they run perfectly.”
“My Central Boiler Classic CL 6048 is a best buy. I use this boiler to heat two houses. We keep our homes at 70 degrees all winter long and it heats our hot water as well. We use dry seasoned wood including whole stumps and pine in the fall and spring. We’ve had it for 13 years and it’s still going strong thanks to proper maintenance and care.
“I have two Deere tractors, a 2000 40-hp. 990 and 2004 30-hp. 790. Both are easy starting, fuel sipping, and good running Yanmar diesels with gear shift transmissions. These simple tractors plow snow, haul wood, snow blow, move dirt, mow, till the garden, chip wood, leaf blow, and grade my 1/2-mile dirt road. I also use a subframe BH80X Woods backhoe with a mechanical thumb to move and hold logs as well as stumping, rock removal, and trenching.”
“My 1981 4440 Deere tractor is still running great. The engine and transmission run like new. I had to put a clutch in it only because some idiot rode the clutch. Otherwise, this is the best tractor I’ve ever owned or heard of.”
“I’ve had quite a few Deere tractors in my time, and they all seem to perform without a lot of breakdowns. I had to split one at the center one time to change an O-ring but that is the only major repair. I’m 85 so I’ve been farming awhile.”
“My 1994 John Deere diesel lawn tractor with a 60-in. deck has 4,250 hrs. on it. I’ve only replaced one fan belt, one injector, and glow plugs. I’ve never had to touch the bearings on the deck. I mow about 3 acres with it. It’s been amazing.”
“I bought a 1962 Deere 2010 gas tractor in 2003. It always starts and runs good. I’ve bush hogged heavy brush with it year after year with no problems.
“In 2020 I bought a new 5220 Branson 55-hp. with a BL200 loader. This is a 4-WD diesel with a 4-cyl. Cummins. So far it’s a ‘best buy’ tractor.”
He likes his Deere tractors but is disappointed with the cost of parts for them. “I was spraying weeds in tall grass with my Deere 2503 when grass got caught in the tractor’s rear axle and ruined the seal. It cost about $2,400 to replace it.
“Last year the plastic hood and cowling on my 2000 Deere 4600 came apart and fell off. The company wanted more than $1,200 to replace them.”
“I upgraded from my Deere 2023 compact loader tractor to a 2025R model, which has bigger tires and better traction but the same bone-jarring ride. The company should install some kind of hydraulic suspension seat.
“My Ariens walk-behind string trimmer equipped with a Kohler engine is very difficult to start and was a worst buy from the get-go. The engine froze up so the dealer replaced it with another Kohler, but it didn’t work much better. I might get the engine started after 20 pulls on the starter rope, or I might not. I contacted the company but they passed the buck and said I should contact Kohler. I own a Bad Boy zero-turn mower equipped with a Kohler engine, and that engine has been trouble-free.”
“I downsized from larger Deere tractors to a 2016 Deere 1025R. I like the quick-disconnect belly mower, quick-disconnect loader, and 3-pt. hitch. I use the tractor almost every day. It has sufficient power for my small farm and the 4-WD ensures I don’t get stuck.
“However, the original fender lights pointed into the back of the bucket so the light bounced back, making the lights useless. I consulted our local dealer, who did not know how the wiring could be re-routed. I contacted Deere and they just wanted to sell me a manual for it. I finally cut the wires and now have LED lights mounted on magnets high on the ROP, which gives me good light.
“My 2016 Kubota RTV 500 goes everywhere. I bought it used but it has performed like new. It is like a mini pickup truck.”
“Over the last 50 years I’ve had good luck with Deere tractors, including 4430, 4020, and 2510 diesels, and a 3010 gas model. All were well-built, nimble, reliable, and powerful.
“Over the years I’ve had trouble with Kohler engines on 3 different zero-turn mowers. These were Command and Courage vertical shaft, twin cylinder engines with 24 and 26 hp. All of the engines developed a knock after about 300 hrs. of use, and one engine blew completely apart. I won’t buy Kohler engines again until they prove themselves to be reliable.”
He likes his Deere tractors but is disappointed with the cost of parts for them. “I was spraying weeds in tall grass with my Deere 2503 when grass got caught in the tractor’s rear axle and ruined the seal. It cost about $2,400 to replace it.
“Last year the plastic hood and cowling on my 2000 Deere 4600 tractor came apart and fell off. The company wanted more than $1,200 to replace them.”
“My new 38-hp. Deere 2038 compact utility tractor is a best buy. Excellent engineering went into this tractor and loader. Very pleased.”
“I use my 2002 Deere lawn tractor to mow our 2-acre lawn, mulch leaves, and blow snow. It still has the original battery, which I think is outstanding.”
“I’m a believer in Deere tractors. In 2014 I bought a used 5525 with a self-leveling loader, and I’ve used it to dig out large rocks and to move about 500 yards of sand to backfill our home’s basement. We bought a 5100E 4-WD tractor last year and it has already proven its worth. We use it with an air blast sprayer on our apple trees and find that it turns much shorter than the 5525. We also use it with a Boss 9-ft. 2-in. V-plow and it’s almost unstoppable for moving snow. The Boss comes with brackets that make it easy to hook up to Deere tractors. Boss and Deere dealers are both great to work with and have promptly corrected any minor problems.
“I’ve owned Massey Ferguson tractors for about 40 years, but I don’t think their new ones are as good. Their utility tractors under 100 hp. are made in third world countries and lack the quality Massey Ferguson was known for.”
“Back in the 1980’s I bought two Caterpillar D4 7U dozers and two Deere tractors - an R and a 1956 70 diesel. All four machines are high quality and still in use today. I think the Deere R was, in its day, the best tractor Deere ever built.”
“In the last issue, various readers talked about trouble with Cub Cadet and John Deere lawn tractors bought at discount home and garden stores. What they probably got was a Murray disguised as a Cub Cadet or Deere. If the serial # on the Cadet starts with a 13, it’s a Murray. If your John Deere serial number starts with a D it’s also a Murray. For me, it was quite a surprise to find I was now the proud owner of a Murray and not a Cub Cadet. Sorry to disappoint all those folks out there who thought they got a deal.”
George says his 1971 International Harvester 1110 pickup “is easy to fix, built rugged, and adaptable to any project. Of course, they don’t make them anymore.”
He has owned 4 Deere tractors over the last 40 years. “My 110 lawn tractor worked well. My 112 lawn tractor broke 7 different axles. Neither the dealer nor the company would pay for the repairs. My third tractor, a 20 hp. 650, needed a new electric front pto clutch but a replacement wasn’t available. The fourth, a 670, came with the poorest front-end loader design I’ve ever seen.”
Over the years, Bruce has had a lot of success with Deere tractors. “I own a 1980 4440 with about 11,000 hours; a 4430 with about 10,000 hours; a 4230 with about 13,000 hours; and a 2955 with about 10,000 hours. None of the engines has ever been touched. The 4440, 4430, and 4230 did require new water pumps.
“All these tractors have actually worked better than me because I had to have my ‘motor’ rebuilt when I turned 82 years old. But I’m now 86 and still going strong.”
“My Deere 2020 loader tractor runs and starts good, and is easy to get on and off.”
“The first Deere tractors I ever bought, a 4440 and a 4240, still run great and have 15,500 hours and 14,000 hours on them, respectively. Neither has been overhauled, and both require only regular maintenance.”
“I have a Deere garden tractor with a front-mounted blade that I use to clear snow off our driveway. I didn’t like the 1-in. wide shoes on back of the blade. They’re too narrow to keep the blade from sinking into wet ground. So I decided to make my own skid plates. They use the same mounting pins and mounting holes and will keep the blade rigid and at a consistent height so you don’t tear up lawns or dig too deep into the gravel.
“The skid plates measure 7 in. wide by 4 in. deep. The blade sets on top of the skid plates, which extend about 1/2 in. ahead of the blade. The blade’s height above the ground can be adjusted by changing the position of a pin. There’s a curled edge on front and back of the skid plates to keep them from catching on anything. To remove the skid plates from the blade you just pull a pair of pins, which can be stored upside down on back of the blade. They sell for $39 per pair plus S&H.”
“I like Deere tractors. Over the years I’ve owned a 1956 Deere 620, a 1964 2510, a 1964 3020, and I still own a 1969 Deere 4020. The 4020 is a great tractor.”
“I thought I was getting the best pickup on the market when I bought my 2005 Toyota Tundra. Boy, was I wrong,” says James. “If I didn’t start the engine every 4 or 5 days the battery would go down and I’d have to jump-start it. I drove the pickup back to the dealer, and the shop foreman said the battery had been drained by the accessories and that I should run the pickup every 2 or 3 days just to keep the battery charged. I don’t use this pickup every day, and I didn’t look forward to jump-starting a brand new pickup. The dealer tried installing a new battery but it didn’t help.
“So I called the dealer again, and this time they told me to bring the pickup in and let it stay overnight which I did. Then they told me the battery had a normal discharge. I told them to install a larger battery in the pickup and they did, which solved the problem. Unfortunately, the warranty had expired and the new battery cost me $138.90, plus four 82-mile trips to town. I think I should have been reimbursed for the mileage and the cost of the larger battery.
“My best buy is my 1966 International Scout and my 1950 M.T. Deere tractor. Both machines still run good.”
“My 1956 Deere model 40 tractor equipped with a Wagner Iron Works front-end loader is my best buy. I’ve used it hard for seven years with very few problems. It’s the best $4,400 I’ve ever spent.
“I paid $90 for my Ryobi garden cultivator six years ago and it’s a best buy. It’s powered by a 31cc, 2-cycle motor that operates a 9-in. rotating cutter at ‘hang on for dear life’ speed. No problems.”
“We have several different brands of trucks on our farm, but Ford is the best. We own Ford pickups, Broncos, and vans, and all have performed great. We also have several old Ford farm trucks that are still as dependable as ever. It’s no wonder Fords have been the best built and best selling trucks for 28 years and running.
“As far as larger tractors go, we’ve had the best luck with our older White models. They’re simple, reliable, rugged and economical machines. Regarding smaller tractors we have the best luck with Fords. It’s a shame to see so many previous companies amalgamated into only a few large companies today.
“Our Fordson Major diesel has 8,614 hours on it and is still going strong.
“Our Deere tractors have always had minor problems. Deere’s service is superb and I like their next-day parts service, but their tractors just seem to have a lot of leaks, start hard, and are also hard to work on, etc. They’re good tractors but not the best on the market.
“We’ve had good luck with Gleaner combines in the past, but I believe the best combines made today are the tried and true Case IH Axial Flow models. They’re simple, reliable, and easy to update. Parts for them are common and they work smoothly and efficiently. We love our Case IH Axial Flow combine.”
“We’ve used Deere tractors over the years, starting with a 1940 model B. We’ve always had one or more on the farm since then. Our latest purchase was a 1997 Deere 7810. We’ve had some minor problems with it including leaking steering cylinders, a hole in the air conditioning line that caused loss of refrigerant, a leaky oil pan gasket that apparently was improperly installed at the factory, and a cab head liner that came loose and dropped down. The dealer didn’t help out on any of these problems. Several of my neighbors have had the same head liner problem in their Deere 7800 series tractors.
“On the plus side, the tractor handles nice and starts right up in cold weather. The cab is roomy and quiet. Also, this tractor is more fuel efficient than our Deere 4440.”
“It starts easy and just keeps on running,” says Cliff about his “best buy” 1972 Deere 2030 tractor. “I bought this tractor used when it was three years old. I’ve used it for both light and heavy duty work, such as harrowing, baling, plowing with a 2-bottom plow, and pulling a 12-ft. offset disk. It now has almost 11,000 hours on it but is still going strong.”
“All of our Deere tractors have been best buys, including a 4450, 4430, 8100, 4020, 2640, and 5520. All of them are easy to operate and reliable, strong performers. The people who designed these tractors put a lot of thought into what they were doing.
“My 1997 Arctic Cat 454 Bearcat ATV is my worst buy. It has had numerous electrical problems and has already gone through seven bal joints. The CV boots split within the first year, and the front end started chattering after only about 18 months. Also, the machine went through a lot of spark plugs, the fan motor burned up, a brake cable locked up, and the gear shifter splines wore out. Resale is terrible”.
“My International Harvester 585 has been a reliable tractor but you tend to forget that after you sit on it awhile because of the lousy ergonomics. Also, this tractor is terribly underpowered.”
“This tractor is a real keeper,” says Larry about his 1961 Deere 2010 utility tractor. “My father bought it new when I was a teenager, and now it’s the only tractor I own. I farm only about 15 acres and use the tractor plowing snow, mowing, and hauling firewood.”
“Our five Deere tractors are all best buys. We own a 4430, 4030, 2630, 2020D, and 3010D. All of them are good tractors and only two have required engine overhauls. FARM SHOW is also a best buy.”
“My worst buy is Uniroyal Loredo tires made by Michelin. After only two years the tread started to separate from the tire. Some steel belts protruded and the tires looked like they were ready to explode. The tires still had a lot of tread depth. I called the company but no warranty or any type of consideration was offered. It’s a poorly built tire from a company that says it makes only ‘perfect tires’.
“My three 1977 Deere tractors are best buys. They include a model 4230 with 5,700 hours on it; a model 2130 with 4,600 hours; and a model 2130 with 3,400 hours. All three have been trouble-free. I have no complaints with any of them.”
“I’m still farming with the Deere tractors that my father bought new in 1968 and 1970 – a 2520, a 2510, a 1020 equipped with a frontend loader, and a 530. They all run nice with very few problems, and if something does go wrong I know how to fix them. I’m 58 years old and have never bought anything new in my life. I take good care of my tractors and keep them in a shed every night.”
“I have two Deere tractors which my dealer seems unable to fix properly. He had one of the tractors longer than I’ve had it and returned it to me with more oil leaks than it had when I sent it to him.
“My all-time worst buy is the Carrier heat pump system I recently installed at my house. It makes so much noise it scares wild turkeys away from our house and it doesn’t pump much heat. Neither the installer nor the company seems able to do anything about it. It’s a $9,000 lemon.”
“My 1950 Allis-Chalmers WD and 1960 Allis-Chalmers D-12 tractors are both best buys. I farmed with them until 1975 when our dealer went out of business. I still own both tractors. They’ve both been overhauled once.
“Since 1975 I’ve been using Deere tractors - a 2030, 2240, 1050 MFWD, 350 dozer, 575 skid steer loader, and 212 and 345 garden tractors. I had to replace a cracked fuel injector on the 2030 five years ago and also replaced a fuel pump on the 2240. The Deere tractors are all best buys, too.
“My New Holland haybine and manure spreader and Fox chopper are best buys. So is my Deere 345 round baler.”
“Your story in the last issue on repowering tractors really struck a nerve. I had previously written to you that I would never buy another Deere tractor after owning an 8960 that was underpowered (until I installed a Schied calibrated fuel pump). Now that I bought a Deere 9400, I’m angry at myself for not sticking to my word.
“The 9400 is ‘almost a tractor’ except that it’s underpowered. I could try to get a computer hacker to boost engine power, but the only component that could possibly be modified would be the fuel injectors. The problem is that the tractor doesn’t seem to put the power to the ground.
“We farmers should be able to make structured power upgrades to our tractors like they do with trucks. I might have Jon Kinzenbaw repower my tractor with a Cummins N14 engine. Then I could paint the Deere engine lemon yellow and mount it on back of the tractor for extra weight.”
“We’ve been using Deere tractors for over 40 years and have never had to replace an engine or transmission,” says John who calls his 4640, 4440, 4230’s and 2240 all “best buys”. “They all have between 4,000 and 7,000 virtually trouble-free hours on them. We had to replace the clutch on the 2240 from overuse.
“We have the fuel pump on one 4230 and the 4440 turned up to give us more power, between 120 to 175 hp.”

Kenneth’s pleased with the five “best buy” Deere tractors he and colleagues use at Keyhole State Park near Moorcroft.
Read the whole story →“I’ve owned several Deere tractors over the years, but my 1995 7400 MFWD model is the best yet,” says Ralph. “It has tremendous lugging power and the Power Quad transmission is excellent. It also has a great cab and controls. It’s an excellent tractor. “My 1995 Dodge 3500 dually pickup equipped with a diesel engine has a lot of pulling power and is easy on fuel. The new-style Dodge pickups are comfortable to operate and a pleasure to drive.”
“I’ve had excellent, trouble-free performance from my Deere tractors. I put 2,500 hours on my 4430, 2,800 hours on my 4640, and 7,800 hours on my 4650. No major problems with any of them. I traded the 4650 for a 1989 Deere 4955 MFWD model and have only one complaint with it - the radiator is difficult to clean. The operator’s manual says ‘lift the hood and slide the condenser out’. However, it should say, ‘phone your neighbor to come and help you lift the hood’. I solved the problem by cutting a door in the right side of the hood with the hinges up and bolts down, using the same size bolts that hold the condenser in place. This allows me to slide the condenser out and lay it on the front axle, providing complete access to the front part of the radiator in less than two minutes. “I made this modification to my 4650 before it even hit the field and also to the 4955. During spring seeding several years ago, the 4640’s used by two neighbors and a 4650 used by another neighbor were running hot because no one has time to mess around cleaning radiators during a busy season. My radiator was running cool. “My most trouble-free combine ever was a 1977 Deere 7701 pull-type model. I used it for 13 years and went through most harvests without stopping. I now have a 1981 Deere 8820. I installed a chaff spreader on it which works well. However, the spreader makes it difficult to access and adjust the sieve. I solved the problem with the steering wheel and cable from an outboard motor boat. I hooked them up to the bottom sieve. The steering wheel mounts outside the cab on the side of the hopper. It took only a few hours to install and required cutting a hole in the side of the combine next to the sieve. It takes 1 1/2 turns of the steering wheel to open and shut the sieve. Both sides of the sieve are tied together and work in unison. A mark on the steering wheel makes a handy reference point for returning to the original sieve setting. “I also installed an electric fan speed control and replaced the original chaffer with an airfoil chaffer that needs no adjustment. It eliminates the need to get off the combine in order to set the chaffer and it lets me adjust the bottom sieve without stopping. From the cab I can check the returns, set the fan speed, watch the grain loss monitor, and see the clean grain in the hopper. Once in a while I check behind the combine just to make sure everything is working right.”
John’s the owner of several “best buy” Deere tractors - a 1991 8760, 1989 4255, 1980 8440, and 1964 4020. “I wouldn’t want any other brand except maybe the Cater-pillar Challenger if a good dealer was nearby. I wish the fuel tanks on the 4-WD models could be filled from either side, and I wish the rear fenders could be folded down or removed so that it would be easier to see and work on forage harvesters and pto-operated combines. I added extra work lights on the 8440 and mounted a Degelman 6-way dozer on it. I also put handle extensions on the remote hydraulic outlets so that I can operate them from behind the tractor. We’re also pleased with our 1995 Deere 740 frontend loader. It’s easy to take on or off and attachments can be changed easily.”
“Over the years we’ve had good luck with our Deere tractors including a 2130 equipped with a 48 front-end loader, 2750 2-WD equipped with a 148 loader, and 2950 4-WD equipped with a 268 loader. We still use our old Deere 60 and 520 models. We also like our Deere 430 round baler and our New Holland haybine.” On the negative side, “I worked parttime for a local tree nursery driving various types of tractors, and I think the worst tractor I drove was a Case-IH 1390. It was one of the first models the company made after Case and International joined. A lot of little things went wrong on it. It had great traction but continually leaked oil and had poor hydraulics.”
JSE William Dorminy, Alapaha, Ga.; “My worst buy and biggest lemon ever is my 1991 7710 Ford 2-WD tractor, The entire tractor has vibrated badly from day one and no one seems to be able to figure out what the problem is. At times the vibration is so bad your hands go numb because the steering wheel shakes so badly. The dealer I bought it from offered to exchange it for a new tractor but he went bankrupt before we were able to do that. I’ve taken it to two other Ford dealers and talked to the regional office in Atlanta, but no one will do anything. They suggested I put new tires on but since the tractor also vibrates when you rev it up at idle, I think the problem’s in the engine or transmission, The tractor vibrates so badly now we're no longer able to use it. “Another problem with the 7710 is that the hydraulics don’t have enough power to pick up a 4-bottom plow and won't turn a hydraulic motor at a constant speed. Also, the air conditioner went out, the clutch had to be replaced, the radio antenna vibrated off, the radio broke, the radiator shook apart and we’ve had many other similar problems.” William says his “best buy” of all time is his 1969 4020 Deere tractor. “It’s a good all-around machine with plenty of power ominate t Buys and it’s easy to handle. I'd buy two more today if they were available.”
Frank Glenn, Farmer City, Ill.: Frank’s impressed with his “Yazoo 60-in. twin 18 Wisconsin mower, This is our second one and it should last until we retire. “Two years ago I traded our Steiger 310 tractor in for a Deere 8960 equipped with a 24-speed transmission and 18.4 by 42 Firestone tires, The Deere tractor has better fuel economy, more power, no separate drop box, much better hydraulics, better traction without tracking, more useable gears, and a much better cab. However, the
( drain hole for the oil panison the side ofthe pan instead of on the bottom. The hoodon the Steiger was easier toraise andhad more clearance, and the drawbar pin lock was easier to operate. The Deere tractor also has a poor oil fill system. It isn’t as easy to enter the cab, and the dash console is very flimsy. _ “T uraded in a Wilrich 45-ft. field cultivator equipped with a 3-bar International coil tine harrow for a DMI 46-ft. Tigermate equipped with a 5-bar spike tooth harrow and Ultra wing sweeps. The DMI has superior trash clearance and does a better job leveling because ithas more wheels. Itfolds narrow for road travel, but the harrow does tangle sometimes. “This is the third year I’ve used my best buy Deere 7200 12-row, 30-in. wing-fold vacuum planter. I previously owned International 500 and 800 vertical wing fold air planters, I liked the fact that the International planters had just two seed boxes and faster markers. However, the Deere planter places the seed at a more even depth and doesn’t have any boots to wear out. It also has a much better monitor. 1 bought four Trotter soybean boxes that hold 8 bu. apiece to help plant bulk beans (Trotter Mfg., Buffalo, IL)”
Frank Lipinski, Buckley, Mich.: q Frank Lipinski, Buckley, Mich.: “Last June we purchased a Farmaster TMR mixer - and our dairy herd average has risen stead ily each month since we installed it. It's well built and does an excellent job of mixing. Our herd average is now 22,800 Ibs. of milk and 921 Ibs. of butterfat. “We also have six Deere tractors with a total of 33,000 hours with practically no down time or repair expense.”
John Leipprandt, Pigeon, Mich.: “It has good power and the comfort ofa smaller / tractor,” reports John, pleased with the Deere , 4455 tractor he leased last year.
Own a John Deere? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.
Your report could appear in a future issue.