John Deere 425 garden tractor
What FARM SHOW readers say · 16 Best Buys5 Worst Buys · Tractors
John Deere 425 garden tractor
16 Best Buys5 Worst Buys“Two years ago, I bought a used 1994 Deere 425 garden tractor. I really like this little thing. It reaches places my larger compact tractor can’t reach. It came with a loader and a snow blade that are really handy. I’d love it to have front-wheel assist, but I’m happy with it for now.
“I try not to buy undesirable stuff, so I thank FARM SHOW for this ‘Best, Worst Buy’ bit. I do read it and hopefully save money because of it.”
“We’ve owned and operated a tilling and mowing service for over 20 years. We run Deere 425 tractors (a 1991 with 4,000 hrs. and a 2001 with 4,200 hrs.) that have both been repowered with Kohler engines. These are the best garden tractors that Deere ever built. Other than general maintenance, we’ve had very little trouble with them, and they’re still going strong.
“My wife owns and operates a 2004 Exmark Lazer Z HP zero-turn mower with a 20-hp. Kohler Command engine with almost 4,000 hrs. and have had almost no trouble or repairs on it. This is a well-built mower. It has the original engine, has never been overhauled, and still operates like new. I’ve replaced one belt and one bearing.
“We also own two 48-in. Walker front-mount deck mowers with the Grass Handling System (GHS). These are excellent mowers for versatility and handling, especially in tight areas, such as mowing around cemetery tombstones, trees, etc. They’re expensive but very well worth it if you want a beautiful job when you’re finished. The electric hopper dump is a wonderful feature.
“We use a 1996 Dodge Ram 1500 4x4 as our ‘workhorse’ in the business. This has been the best pickup that I’ve ever owned. It has 260,000 miles on it and has had few repairs other than a new transmission at 202,000 miles and replaced two U-joints in the front axles.”
“In 1995 I bought a used Deere 425 riding mower with 167 hrs. on it. I traded in my Deere 318 riding mower but kept the snowplow that I had used with it. The snowplow’s frame didn’t fit the new machine, so I made an adapter bracket for it. I also added a shut-off valve so I can operate both the snowplow and the mower deck without having to take either one off. This mower has more than 4,000 hrs. on it now but is still going strong.”
His Deere 425 zero-turn riding mower turned out to be a lemon. “I spent about $2,500 to keep this mower going. I had to replace both transmissions, the carburetor and manifold, and numerous spark plugs and filters but the company didn’t seem to care. I’ve always been 100 percent Deere, but not any more.”
“I haven’t had any problems with this pickup, and that’s the way a truck should be,” says Tom, pleased with his 2004 Chevrolet Silverado Z71 pickup.
“My Deere 425 lawn tractor is my worst buy, because it’s a major ordeal to get the mower started every time I use it. It’s been this way from day one. The engine starts fine but it will stall more than a dozen times before the blades engage. The dealer has been no help and charges me $50 every time he looks at it - even under warranty. He cleaned out the deck one time and replaced a defective switch another time, but the problem still persists. Now the tractor is out of warranty so I’m stuck. It’s giving me marriage problems, because I have to force my wife to use this tractor when she’d rather use my old Wheelhorse.”
“I’m well satisfied with my 1985 Massey Ferguson 1040 diesel tractor equipped with a Massey Ferguson 232 front-end loader. And I like my 1998 Deere 425 garden tractor equipped with a 54-in. mower deck. Both tractors are well-built and have required only routine maintenance.”
On the minus side, “The transmission on my 2001 Ford Escape failed at 51,000 miles. It happened when I was 250 miles from home and after the warranty had expired. The transmission cost $3,300 to repair and was at the dealer for 2 1/2 weeks. I also had to spend $400 on a rental car while the vehicle was in the shop. I immediately replaced the Ford with a 2003 GM Envoy, which I really like. However, just in case anything goes wrong I bought it with an extended 100,000-mile warranty.”
“My worst buy is my 1999 Deere 425 all-wheel-steer mower equipped with a 60-in. deck. I’ve put only about 200 hours on it but have already had problems with the camshaft and throttle knob, as well as the valve cover gasket. Also, the taillight assemblies won’t stay inside the fenders. Another aggravating problem is that grass clippings accumulate on the tractor’s screens and on the platform. Also, whenever I use high lift blades the mower leaves 1-in. wide uncut grass strips at each blade overlap.
“Mowing in wet conditions with this mower isn’t possible because clippings immediately accumulate on the underside of the deck. Even in dry conditions, clippings have to be removed after each mowing. You have to raise the front end of the tractor with an overhead hoist and then use a putty knife to remove the caked-on clippings, a process that takes about 15 minutes. I expected better performance, quality and reliability in an $8,000 machine.”
“In a recent issue I read about someone dissatisfied with their Deere 425 riding mower. I was worried because I took delivery of a 425 that very same day,” he says. “But green paint did not let me down- I have found it to be a quality product. Especially useful is the all-wheel steer with power steering,” says Moege. “It makes mowing in tight places easy.
“The Deere 425 is an all around excellent product with solid engineering and great maneuverability. It’s my best buy.”
“My Deere 425 riding mower equipped with a 54-in. deck is my worst buy. I wish I could get my money back. The deck works well when it’s clean, but it takes only a short time for grass to begin sticking to the entire inside part of the deck. It’s too much work to remove the deck so I bought a small electric winch and mounted it on front of the mower. Now when I’m done mowing I hitch the mower to a heavy tree branch and raise the front end of the mower to a vertical position so that I can easily hose it off. To power the winch I replaced the rig’s original small battery with a larger car battery. Now I don’t swear at the mower nearly as often.”
“My 1996 Deere 425 riding mower is my best buy. It starts and runs like new and does every job we ask it to do. It’s also a pleasure to drive. I’d buy another one if something ever happened to this one.”
“It cuts the grass very evenly and turns short so it has great maneuverability,” says Darrell, pleased with his 2001 Deere 425 lawn and garden tractor.”
“My 2000 Deere 425 garden tractor is my best buy. I owned a smaller Deere garden tractor for 10 years before I bought this model. It still has the same great quality.”
“My 1993 Ford 5610 II tractor equipped with wide rear tires and an extra flow hydraulic pump is a best buy.
“My Sears Craftsman high wheel trimmer is my worst buy. The problem is that it leaks oil. I should’ve known better because I had previously owned a Sears riding mower which needed repairs almost every week. However, when my DR trimmer finally wore out I decided to try Sears one more time, which was a mistake.”
“I’m unhappy with my 1993 Deere 425 riding mower. It’s priced like a Cadillac but runs like an old Ford. The water-cooled engine is supposed to have 20 hp. The company brags about how many acres per hour this mower will cut, but for every acre I’ve cut, I’ve had to spend another hour blowing trash out of the radiator. Does anyone have a solution?”
“We’re pleased with our Deere 425 all-wheel steering riding mower. We have about 3 acres to mow and there are at least 150 trees of various sizes to work around. Before we bought this mower, we spent as much time trimming as we did mowing. Now we do nearly all of it in one pass. I’m amazed at how well this machine maneuvers and how easy it is for new drivers to learn to drive it. Maintenance hs been virtually non-existent, some of which is because we keep the blades sharp and the underside of the deck clean.”
A 1998 Deere 5410 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader and a cab, air conditioner, and heater rates as Charles’ “best buy”.
He’s also happy with his Deere 425 garden tractor equipped with a 54-in. mower deck. “It’s a 20 hp model so it has a lot of power for mowing my lawn. It has reduced my mowing time by up to one hour compared to the 18 hp mower I had been using.
“My 1999 GM Sierra Classis 1500 series pickup has performed exactly as I expected. It’s a best buy.”
Mike’s been cutting his own firewood for 18 years and says he’s never had a chain saw as dependable as the 1996 Stihl 044 he’s using now. “I’ve always come back from the woods fully loaded, unlike some of the times I came back empty with other brand chain saws. It’s a very aggressive cutter and is easy on gas. It’s needed no repairs.”
Mike also likes his 1995 Deere 425 lawn tractor but he’s had trouble with the mower’s 54-in. deck. “In heavy or high grass, it discharges poorly. The company has tried to correct the problem and offered to buy it back from me so I can upgrade to a 60-in. deck. Unfortunately, the bigger deck is too wide for my property.”
A 1995 Ford F-150 XLT Lariat 4-WD pickup heads Ernest’s “best buy” list. “It looks good and is built with quality. It has a great paint job, drives good, and performs well for having a 302 cu. in. electronic fuel injected engine. It gets 14 to 16 mpg around home and 18 to 19 mpg on the highway. “My 1996 Deere 425 all-wheel-steer riding mower equipped with a 60-in. deck is the best mower I’ve ever owned. It gets around just as fast as a zero turn mower but rides much smoother.”
“I’m impressed with my 1996 Case-IH 7220 front wheel assist tractor. It’s the first piece of red equipment I’ve ever owned. So far it has performed beyond my expectations. It has a lot of power, is fuel efficient, and the transmission runs smooth with excellent gear selections. It has a nice cab with good visibility, a wide door, and easy-to-reach controls. It’s not often you can buy something new without having a few problems. But after one year and 400 hours, no problems. I couldn’t have finished plowing last fall without the front wheel assist.
“My 1995 Deere 425 all wheel steer riding lawn mower equipped with a 54-in. deck is easy to use and is comfortable. We had a couple of minor problems on it which the dealer promptly fixed. It’s an easy machine to operate and has cut our mowing time in half.”
“I’m impressed with my 1996 Case-IH 7220 front wheel assist tractor. It’s the first piece of red equipment I’ve ever owned. So far it has performed even beyond my expectations. It has a lot of power, is fuel efficient, and the transmission runs smooth with excellent gear selections. It has a nice cab with good visibility, a wide door, and easy-to-reach controls. It’s not often you can buy something new without having a few problems. But after one year and 400 hours, no problems. I couldn’t have finished plowing last fall without the front wheel assist. “My 1995 Deere 425 all wheel steer riding lawn mower equipped with a 54-in. deck is easy to use and is comfortable. We had a couple of minor problems on it which the dealer promptly fixed. It’s an easy machine to operate and has cut our mowing time in half.”
“I like my 1994 Deere 425 all wheel steer riding mower. It runs good and cuts great. It’s in a class by itself.”
Terry Senstrum, Elko, Minn.: A 1993 Deere 425 riding mower equipped with a 60-in. deck and all-wheel-steering tops Terry’s list of best buys. “I can mow my 4 1/2-acre yard in 3/4 hours now. The V2 engine is quiet and has lots of torque. I can cut around trees easily thanks to all-wheelsteering.”
Own a John Deere? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.
Your report could appear in a future issue.