Craftsman: what farmers say
66 reports in FARM SHOW · 47 Best Buys20 Worst Buys
Craftsman (general)
11 Best Buys5 Worst Buys“I purchased a Craftsman mechanic’s creeper from Sears more than 30 years ago, way before Sears began shuttering its stores. Overall, it was well-made and even folded in half for storage. The big issue I had with it was that when I used it under a vehicle and leaned to one side to reach something underneath, it would always tip over, and the opposite side would come up. I’d then need to reposition my body so it wouldn’t happen again, but it always did. I always meant to toss it out and buy something better, but never did.
“I recently replaced the casters on my workbench with Dicasal 3-in. heavy-duty casters I purchased on Amazon and wondered whether the same casters would work on my mechanic’s creeper, so I bought another set of four. The creeper’s casters were 2 in. in diameter and very narrow. The new ones are not only an inch larger in diameter but also much wider. The downside was that, although they were stem casters like the ones I replaced, the stems weren’t long enough to go completely through the frame, so I had to weld the mounting nuts that came with them to the bottom of the creeper. I was absolutely floored by the improvement this made—no more tilting over, and it moves so much easier now.”
“I like my 2022 Echo SRM-2620 trimmer. It has plenty of power and easy string line replacement. I owned my previous Echo for 15 years with only minor repairs.
“My 2019 Craftsman 25-cc is short on power, and you need three hands to rewind the string line.”
Francis Deters, Seneca, Kan.: Francis had had bad luck with his Sears Craftsman V5 1/4-in drills and 6 to 7 1/2-in. high speed grinders. “The 1/4-in V5 lasted about two hours; the 3/8-in. about 150 hours before the armature burned out. My four Craftsman high speed grinders each lasted from 18 to 21 hours. Sears sent me a new one and that lasted around 10 hours. It'll be my last one. I'll never even look at a Sears catalogue again. “I always had good luck with Chevrolet trucks. My old 1975 inline 6 cyl. started like a charm and was a real mountain climber. My 1988 Chevy 4.3 liter V-6 gets 24 mpg on dirt roads, 27 mpg on the highway, and 31 mpg with a tailwind, It doesn’t start as well as the inline 6, maybe because the firing order in the V-6 is kind of crazy.”
Oliver Drummond, Keota, Okla.: Oliver's happy with his Campbell Hausfeld 60 HZ air compressor. “It’s got quick air pressure recovery and maintains good steady pressure for painting, spraying, and degreasing. It’s given me two years of solid service with nothing but an oil change and lube every year. It also provides plenty of power for sand blasting. “My worst buy is a toss-up between my Murray 12 hp. 38-in. cut side delivery mower and my Craftsman sand blaster from Sears. The mower throws grass everywhere and won't cut grass with more than a week's growth without stalling. The sand blaster works poorly and it’s almost impossible to get new nozzles for it.”
Gerald Grant, Nevada, Iowa: Gerald’s impressed with his 1991 Deere 875 12-row, 30-in. high residue row crop cultivator. “It’s well built and can handle a lot of trash and stays in the ground regardless of how hard the ground is. We're pretty much Case-IH customers. We bought this cultivator because our local Case-IH dealer couldn't get acultivator that we had ordered seven months earlier and we needed it. We couldn't be happier with it. “Sears Craftsman electric-powered shop tools have lost some of their quality. For example, on drills the chucks slip and won’t hold bits, switches fail, and the motors burn out. We’ve started buying Makita electric hand tools.”
John Pierskalla, St. Cloud, Minn.: “Two years ago I boughta Sears Craftsman circular saw for $75. It’s an expensive piece of junk. I didn’t even get to use it long enough to sharpen the blade before a short developed in the armature. The company wants $59 to repair it. It's more than a year old so it’s no longer covered by warranty.”
James Smith, Hamlin, N.Y.: James likes his 1990 Makita 10 mm drill. “I’ve used it for over a year with no problems. In the past I’ve used Black & Decker, Craftsman, and Skil drills, but none of them lasted more than six months.” On the “worst buy” side, he’s unhappy with his 1989 Ford F-150 pickup. “I had problems with the engine, transmission, power steering, springs, and brakes. The pickup was in the shop 25% of the time. Finally I returned it to the manufacturer under New York's lemon law.”
Billy Averitte, Vanleer, Tenn.: Billy says his Taylorway-JF model 410 hay tedder “does a great job on green and wet hay and is a best buy. The 3-pt. hitch mount comes in handy for lifting the tedder on turns at the end of the field and for transport. This tedder didn't cost an arm and a leg like the big name brands.” On the negative side, “My Campbell Hausfield 2 hp direct drive air compressor is a worst buy, After two months of light use, the motor quit running. I exchanged it foranew one thatruns fine in warm weather, but can’t power the compressor in cool weather. After it blew several fuses I unplugged it until summer came again. I'll probably replace it with a Craftsman.”
Jerico Springs, Mo.: “I bought a 180 amp Lincoln welder in 1967 and it's been an all-time best buy. | run a tractor repair shop so it gets a workout. I'm also pleased with Sears Craftsman tools. They're built the best and replacement parts are easy to get. Snap-On tools are the worst, I'd break a ratchet every two weeks or so. The Snap-On dealer said he couldn't do anything for me. Sears ratchets last about a year doing the same work and when they finally get to the point where | can’t fix them, I get a free new replacement ratchet from Sears. Snap-On won't do that for me.”
Lawrence Dool, Thorsby, Alb.: "IT bought my 1968 Ford 630 combine in 1980. It'd been parked for about 7 years when I bought it. All it needed was a fuel pump and a battery and it took right off. I've used it for 6 years with no additional repairs. With its 50-in, cylinder and Melroe pick-up, I don't think there's another combine that can compete with it capacity wise.” He nominates his Sears Craftsman electronic 3/8-in. drill as "worst buy". "The automatic chuck doesn't work properly, the switch fell out several times, it powers out and the variable speed goes up and down on it. In other words, it's pure junk. You'd expect better service for a $139 drill, especially since my $30 Black & Decker that's 17 yrs. old outperforms it by a long shot."
L. Merrill, Grantsville, Maryland: "He nominates his Sears Craftsman hand-grinders as "worst buy”. "The gears went out on a 7-in, grinder, Then I bought a 10-in. grinder and the armature burned out before the first grinding disk wore oul.” Ralph Cottrell, Waterloo, New York: "We're well-pleased with our Deutz 4506 tractor. It has 4,000 hrs and has performed real well. The machine is fuel efficient, handy and has lots of power for its size." He's not as happy with his Last Perch sparrow trap. "I bought it a year ago. I've put it in 3 different locations and haven't caught a sparrow yet.”
Paul Nottingham, Nunica, Mich.: “My 1/2-in. Milwaukee electric drill motor is expensive but rugged. I ran over it with a pickup but didn’t hurt it. It can be operated steady for over an hour honing a cylinder block and hardly get warm.” He’s not as happy with his Sears Craftsman micro-torque click-stop torque wrench. “From the beginning, it failed to click when set torque was reached. I sent it back to factory for repair. Two months later got it back and it did exactly the same thing as before. I threw it away.”
Ted Criblez, Bluffton, Ohio: “'! really like the KMN Niemeyer power harrow as it does everything it’s supposed to and has been troublefree on thousands of acres. The problem is finding repair parts. The dealer and distributor have gone out of business and the importer’s either moved or gone out of business. I'd like to find somebody who has a used one for sale. “My Craftsman cordless %-in.
Norman Foellmi, Sparta, Wis.: ‘‘] bought a Suzuki 125 4-wheeler just before Christmas and told my wife it Se linate suys was her Christmas present. She wasn't too happy with it at first but I added a tray on the front and she now uses it to go to the garden, run errands and to check cattle. use it to fix fence and shut gates,"’ says Norman. His “‘worst buy” is a Craftsman battery charger on wheels. ‘It seemed like what I needed to boost-start and charge my tractors and truck. I'd put it on high charge and it would charge at % the advertised rate and then drop down to 10 amps within 5 minutes. I returned it and bought a used solar battery charger that puts out as rated.”
William Fricke, Petersburg, Ill.: William's pleased with his 1985 Vicon double wide hay rake. ‘Does twice the work of one rake with just one tractor and one operator, Has few | moving parts, gently turns hay andI get less leaf loss.”’ Jake Van Eps, Hancock, Minn.; “‘It always seems to be falling apart and nobody seems to want it in trade,” reports Jake, upset with his Bolens | lawnmower. As “best buy" he cites his 1971 | 4020 Deere tractor. “We've not had any expense On it outside of a new clutch. It has over 5000 hrs. on it and doesn’t use any oil." Burton W. Bartz, Princeton, Minn.; “My New Idea 363 manure spreader is a best buy. The worm gear driveis | very smooth and pulls extremely easy for such a large spreader.” Mark Stiegman, Thawville, Ill. “If this was the only bait on the market, the world would be engulfed with rats. I think it’s a complete waste of money,” says Mark, disappointed with Rampage Rat Bait. ‘Placed it side by side with five other brands. Rodents never touched it although other brands were readily consumed," Brian Klapak, Warren, Ohio; ‘My best buys are all Ford products, Lown 7710 and 4610 tractors. They start easily and operate smoothly. The canopies are like a shade tree and the dealer is one of the best in the business. A 1985 Ford XLT Lariat pickup is also a best buy. Rides excellent and gets good mileage. On the negative side, Brian's unhappy with his 1978 Case 1410 tractor. It leaked oil everywhere and the 3-pt. hitch took a genius to operate, Injector pump went out at 1,000 hrs.”’ Daryl Semerad, Dickinson, N. Dak.: ‘‘Stress points are wellreinforced and it has heavier axles and bigger tires than comparable brands," reports Daryl, happy with his 1983 Kiefer 6 by 16-ft. Stockmaster stock trailer. He nominates his 1985 Sears Craftsman variable speed, reversible ¥-in. drill as ‘worst buy”. ‘I only drilled four holes with it in a year's time and the motor burned out just one month after the warranty ran out. I thought Craftsman had better quality tools than this.” Lester Evers, Windom, Minn.; “My 1981 Buick diesel car only had 45,000 miles on it and blew the engine. Buick said “too bad’, | wound up trading for anew car. Once you havea diesel, you're stuck or you'll lose a lot of money.” On the positive side, Lester says, “My 295-250 AC-DC Century welder is easy to operate and will run a 7018 rod smoothly and will do a beautiful job that will hold. My 8070 Allis Chalmers tractor with mfwd has a cab that is tops. The tractor will pull at reduced throttle and come right back Bh nn eee eee Ed ae rst Buys in rpm's under load. With the front wheels pulling, you can go through mud or up hills with little or no slippage. Tractor starts good even in cold weather. It's far better than my old 7060, “IT also like my 1981 Gleaner M2 combine. It’s always done a good job and gives me very little trouble.”
Waldo Stinson, Owosso, Mich: He's pleased with Craftsman’s 1/2 in, electric impact wrench, “Sure speeds up changing the combine from grain to dry beans, then to corn and back to grain. We also use it for other jobs in the shop.”
Craftsman 3/8-in drive ratchet
2 Best Buys2 Worst BuysRandy Kinzler, Hebron, Neb.: “It's well designed and should last for many years,” reports Randy, pleased with his 1993 Troy-Bilt Pony 5 hp garden tiller, “It takes only one hand to operate it, just like their ads say. “My Skil 6225 3/8-in. variable speed drill is my worst buy. It was cheap and I got what paid for. It got hot and started squealing after only five hours of use. It's not nearly as well made as the Craftsman 3/8-in. drill that I had previously owned, I exchanged it for a Black & Decker 3/8-in. ‘Blockbuster’ drill which I really like.”
Ronald J. Swank, Bellville, Ohio: “I’ve had good luck with my 1992 Skil 2503 cordless drill. It has plenty of power and the charge lasts much longer than expected, It’s also lightweight which makes it easy to handle even in awkward positions, “My 1985 Chevrolet S-10 pickup is also “My 14-year-old son hopes that I'm ready to buy a new pickup in two years so he can have this one.” a best buy. It’s equipped with a 4-speed transmission and 2.8-liter V-6 engine that has plenty of power to pull a 1,500 Ib. load. It’s trouble-free and fun to drive. My 14year old son hopes that I'm ready to buy a new pickup in two years so he can have this one.” “My Sears Craftsman 3/8-in. drive ratchet is my worst buy. The ratchet gear broke so I took it back to the company. Instead of replacing the ratchet they gave me a rebuild kit with parts made so poor that once they were installed, the ratchet wouldn't work.”
Paul Hobbs, Kansas City, Mo.: “My Makita 4-in, grinder is easy to handle, compact, and has an overload shutoff. It’s a best buy. “My Homelite XL 14-in. chain saw is light and easy to handle. I’ve used it for six years and my only expenses have been fora new filter and new chains. “My Craftsman 3/8-in. electric drill is a worst buy. After I used it about 10 times it started making a howling noise. [ retumed it and got another one, but the same problem happened again.”
Rick Gilmore, Beeville, Texas: “I wouldn't recommend that anyone buy this lawn tractor,” says Rick, unhappy owner of a 1987 Craftsman 38-in., 10 hp model, “It won't hold a charge, doesn’t seal out moisture, the starter locks up constantly, and the mower belts and the governor keep breaking.”
Craftsman lawn mower
4 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My best buy is a 1998 Craftsman lawn mower with a 42-in. deck and a Briggs & Stratton 14.5-hp OHV I/C Gold engine. It still runs great, and we only do normal maintenance. A lot of people had it before us. My grandparents bought it for their friend, who left it at a rental property my aunt owns. When my aunt moved, she gave it to us. We’ve never had to do any major repairs, except when the shifter broke. We were able to fix it. We use it to mow tall grass, and it cuts perfectly.”
“Since June 2021, I’ve been driving a 2021 GMC Sierra X31 4x4 pickup truck with the Duramax diesel engine. It’s a 3.0 liter, straight 6-cylinder engine. I have 50,000 miles on it and have had zero issues with it. It has plenty of power and pep. Plus, I regularly get over 30 mpg on it. With a good tailwind and driving at 55 mph, I averaged 54.9 mpg over a 25-mile period. That’s my best mileage to date. I recommend it to anyone.
“I recently bought a walk-behind, rear-wheel drive Craftsman 21-in. lawn mower. I average close to 5 hrs. a week pushing a lawn mower. My previous mowers were very similar to the one I recently bought, but they were front-wheel drive. I like the rear-wheel drive version much better.”
“My 1992 Craftsman riding lawn mower with 20-hp. OHV Briggs & Stratton motor is a best buy. All I’ve done is an oil filter and oil change every spring and spent $30 on new coils about five years ago. It fires up and runs like a champ. I’m most amazed that the DieHard battery is the second one I put in it 28 years ago under warranty. I know that’s hard to believe but I’m a 75 year old maintenance man and I keep records on everything.
“I’ve also bought 22 Ryobi items in 20 years and haven’t had a problem.”
“My best buy is a 20-in. Craftsman mower I bought 50 years ago. It has a 3 hp Briggs & Stratton motor and a heavy white metal deck. It’s been abused, left out exposed to rain, and it was buried under our greenhouse when it collapsed due to snow. I thought it was ¿ nished but I gave it a couple pulls. Despite the stale gas, it started right up and is still running perfect.”
Craftsman cordless tools
4 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“I have five Craftsman cordless tools, including a set of pruners like the one a reader recommended in Vol. 49, No. 4. I chose Craftsman because I didn’t want a bunch of different chargers and batteries that don’t interchange. My son needed pruning shears, and I was tempted to buy the ones a reader wrote about in Vol. 49, No. 5. When I checked Amazon, the price had dropped to $75, but several other pruners were listed for $35.”
“I like my Milwaukee M18 Fuel leaf blower. It works well to clean leaves and chaff off equipment and light snow off sidewalks as well as to blow soybean pods out of soybeans while unloading.
“My one-handed Milwaukee Hackzall is handy for trimming small branches. I carry it along on my lawnmower to trim branches as I go by.
“My 19.2-volt Craftsman tools are good but have poor battery life.”
“My 2011 Echo PAS-265 multi-head power unit with different attachments starts and runs great. It has required minimal maintenance.
“My 2011 Grasshopper 223 zero-turn mower has a rear discharge and is great on gas. With rear discharge, you can wear your Sunday suit, mow your lawn, and wear the same suit to church afterward. Amazing!”
Glenn hasn’t been as pleased with Craftsman power tools. “Every one of the six or seven I’ve purchased has broken after limited use.”
Lewis J. Bugna, Elgin, Ill.: He's impressed with Craftsman hand tools. “I bought my first 1/2-in, drive Crafisman ratchet 37 years ago for $3.25. I wore out two of them and now am on my third model. They're unconditionally guaranteed for life.” Rudolph B, Wellnitz, Cranbury, N.J.: He nominates his 1991 Westfield 7-in. dia., 51-ft. long pto drive auger as his “best buy”. “It’s well built, simple to set up, and trouble free. The flighting design reduces grain damage, especially to soybeans, “T had to buy a new radiator core for my Allis Chalmers L2 combine. The radiator cooling fins are sized differently on front and back which prevents chaff from passing through. I have to wash out the cooling fins about once an hour on hot days, The core cost $1,200. The dealer wouldn't take the old core back or admit there was a problem.”
Craftsman 1/2-in impact
3 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My Craftsman 1/2-in. impact is easy to use around the farm. It has a good battery life. There’s no need for a generator or power cord.”
Marcus Yoder, Grove City, Minn.: “I'm impressed with my Black & Decker 14-in. chop saw, Makita 4-in, hand grinder, and Lincoln 225-amp welder. They've all had steady use over the past 10 years and performed well. “My Craftsman 1/2-in. drill is built too light. The handle broke off the first year I used it.”
Bill Short, Hamilton, Mo.: Bill likes his Sears Craftsman 1/2-in, 3/4 hp electronic variable speed reversible drill. “The quick change automatic chuck lets me change drill bits instantly. It's a safe drill to use because the electrical componentsare double insulated. Very good availability of parts and service. It has plenty of power for tough drilling jobs.”
Craftsman 18 hp riding lawn
1 Best Buy1 Worst BuyArnold Shackelford, Long Green, Md.: “My best buy is my 1990 Sears Craftsman 18 hp riding lawn mower. It's been troublefree.”
Jerry Neese, Afton, Va.: Jerry’s had problems with his Sears Craftsman 18 hp lawn and garden tractor. “Every time I use it the belts twist and turn which locks the tractor up. The belt guides are poorly made. The tractor itself isn’ tthat well built, but the mower is really bad.”
Craftsman 20-volt cordless pruning shears
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“My 2024 Craftsman cordless 20-volt pruning shears are the best thing since sliced bread. They make it effortless to trim tree limbs and other branches up to 1 1/4 in. in diameter. I use them daily.
“My 2017 LS XR335H has to be the worst tractor I’ve ever owned. I’ve had Kubota, Deere and other brands. This LS tractor has tons of good features, but it’s as dependable as wet toilet paper. The computer is continuously causing it to stop.”
“I bought a 2001 Chevy 2500 HD pickup with 140,000 miles on it. I just retired it with 287,000 miles. Best value for the money (paid $8,500). We rolled it upside down 3 years ago on black ice and still drove it every day. It did everything I ever needed it to do. The rust killed it thanks to Pennsylvania and New Jersey brine. These are the longest-lasting trucks on the road.
“My Craftsman 20-volt weed wacker takes three times as long to wack my weeds, and the battery only lasts 20 mins., but takes all night to charge.”
Craftsman 4 1/2-in angle grinder
2 Best Buys0 Worst BuysTwo of Clifford’s “best buys” are a Honda Foreman 400 ATV and a Deines 1800 KT lawn his Craftsman 4 1/2-in. angle grinder and Craftsman 3/8-in. electric drill “Both are equipped with Unity motors that burned up after a few hours use. Rather than return them under warranty, I tossed them and purchased DeWalt replacements which are much better built.”
Larry B. Clark, Middlebury, Vt.: Larry likes his Craftsman 4 1/2-in. industrial grinder. “It’s fast and powerful and has a wire cup brush that works great for cleaning rust and old paint. It does as good a job as a sand blaster but without the mess. It’s a great addition to our shop.”
Craftsman electric chainsaw
1 Best Buy1 Worst BuyRichard nominates his Harbor Freight Portland electric pole saw and Craftsman 10-in. electric chainsaw as best buys. “I’ve been clearing a brush pile from the recent hurricane and cutting 12-in. limbs with no problems.
“The battery on my Black & Decker 20-volt weedeater (LST201) only lasts about 20 min. It’s been doing this since I bought it new. It’s aggravating.”
“I really like my Worx 56-volt leaf blower. It has plenty of power and much more air than a DeWalt 20-volt. I use it to clean up my cement drive after mowing, my flower beds in the fall, and light snow in the winter. However, the battery has died after almost seven years, and new batteries are no longer available. I sent my battery to MTO Battery (www.mtobattery.com; ph 717-751-2705). It was returned within 10 days. The blower is as strong as it ever was and lasts as long as when it was new. I definitely recommend MTO Battery.
“On the negative side are my gas string trimmer and Craftsman chainsaw. They’re very frustrating to get started. I get them running great one year, and by the next year, the plastic gas lines are disintegrating, and I have to play with them when I’m trying to get something done. After a few years of this, my solution is cordless tools.”
Craftsman compact hammer drill
1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy“A best buy was a Craftsman compact hammer drill and set of battery power tools purchased 30 years ago at Sears. They’ve been well used in demo and construction. If the old dry yellow pine lumber is too hard for the 12-volt, the 19-volt big brother has plenty of power to twist your wrist or a screw off.”
“My 2002 Deere 4100 with 410 loader is great. I’ve only changed the oil and filter, nothing else. It still has the original battery.
“My 2002 Grasshopper 740K mower has only had oil and filter changes plus a new battery.
“My worst buy was a Craftsman battery-operated drill.”
Craftsman ratcheting wrenches
0 Best Buys2 Worst Buys“I repowered my Deere 318 garden tractor with a Vanguard 18-hp. engine. It has much more power and is quieter and more fuel efficient. The engine switch didn’t take long at all.
“My Craftsman ratcheting wrenches were poor quality. The ratcheting parts quit working far too soon.”
Bruce A. Wolff, Naperville, IL: “It works harder and runs better than any other truck I own,” says Bruce about his 1986 International 9670 semi that he bought used 1 1/2 years ago. “The Cummins engine is easy to service and gets good fuel mileage. “My worst buy are Craftsman ratchet box-end wrenches. They break every time I have to bear down on them.”
Craftsman 10-in
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyMark Anderson, Preston, Idaho: Mark names his Sears Craftsman 10-in. table saw as “worst buy”. ‘The pulleys, belts, rip fence and other parts constantly work out of adjustment. The 1-hp. motor also needs resetting on a regular basis. Poor engineering causes the belt and pulleys to almost always rub somewhere.
Craftsman 12 hp riding lawn
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysFrank Grosvenor, New Vienna, Ohio: “It starts easy, is easy on gas, and has plenty of power,” says Frank about his “best buy” 1990 Sears Craftsman 12 hp riding lawn mower, maintain. Thanks to the double twine wrap, we can make and wrap a bale every two minutes in good windrows.”
Craftsman 2.3 cu
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyGene Stout, Elizabethtown, Ind.: “My best buy is my 1990 Polaris Trail Boss 4WD ATV. I've used it almost every day to cut wood, to clean fence rows and ditch banks, and to pull a trailer while gleaning “It's trouble-free and so easy to handle that all my neighbors want to borrow " a a eens) cor fields. It’s trouble-free and economical. made a tool box for the front rack to carry fuel, chain saws, and axes.” Gene says another “best buy” is his 1988 Bush Hog 2615 15-ft. flex wing rotary cutter, “I use it to mow road sides, creek banks, drainage ditches, corn stalks, and pastures, lLleaves pastures looking like lawns and does an excellent job of mowing over rough terrain. The wings can be raised or lowered for use on roadsides and ditch banks, and I can sharpen the blades without removing them. “My Craftsman 2.3 cu. in. chain saw equipped with a 16 in, low-kick guide bar is a worst buy. I use it only to trim fruit trees and wood after trees have been cut down, but last fall it quit running. The cylinder came loose and damaged internal parts beyond repair. I had to junk it.”
Craftsman 3/4-in electric drill
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyCoy Prokup, Porum, Okla.: Coy says his 1990 Sears Craftsman 3/4-in, electric drill is a “worst buy”. “The chuck cracked “T can't believe what this tractor can do.” the first time used itso I returned itand got my money back. Then bought a 3/8-in. Craftsman electric drill. The first ime used it the chuck froze up and I couldn't get the bit out. I returned it also. Sears used to put out the best material and workmanship. Today they put out junk.” On the “best buy” side, “My Makita 14in. cutoff saw cuts fast. No problems.”
Craftsman 3.7 chainsaw
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysDavid is happy with his 1987 Craftsman 3.7 20-in. chainsaw. “This has been a reliable, hardworking saw since day one. I believe that the fact that it called for a 25-to-1 gas mixture allowed for better lubrication, leading to longer engine life. I’ve stuck with the same mixture on my newer saws, with the same long-lasting results.”
On the negative side are PowerCare chain files. “These chain files are made in China. After using them for a couple of sharpenings, they no longer cut without excessive pressure. I now only buy files made in Germany or Sweden. Oregon files used to be good, but now some are made in China.”
Craftsman 3-ton jack
1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy“My Craftsman 3-ton jack is a good product and will lift a 1-ton truck front end. However, the valve is faulty, and after a year of use, it starts to bleed while in use. They could use grease points.
“Fram $4 oil filters and Walmart brand oil filters are of poor quality. The oil appears to have been used without a filter after 1,500 miles in my gas truck. They’re the worst product line and need to be improved.”
Craftsman 7 1/4-in hand powered saw
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyRalph Watkins, Effingham, Ill.: Ralph's had problems with his Sears Craftsman 7 1/4-in. hand powered saw. “After about 50 hours of use the motor bumed out. The company replaced it, but the new one lasted only a lite longer before burning out.” On the positive side, “My 1980 International F2575 semi tractor has 386,000 miles and is equipped with a V-6 Detroit diesel engine and an automatic transmission. I use it to pull a 38-ft. hopper bottom grain trailer. It does real well in the field and is a pleasure to drive. Very few repairs. Good maintenance has really paid off.”
Craftsman 8
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyD.D. Montgomery, Fair Play, Mo.: “My 1992 Sears Craftsman 8 hp 30-in. riding mower is my worst buy. The first time I used it I didn’t have any problems. The second time I used it, the bagging equipment kept plugging up. I finally had to remove the bagger. It continued to plug up but not as often. The deck cracked at the discharge port and I had to weld it back together. It uses gas like a 20 hp engine butonly has the power of a5 hp. The drive belt and steering apparatus broke.”
Craftsman I’m 81 tools
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I liked Craftsman tools for many years (I’m 81). But I’m no longer a fan – they should change the name to ‘Crapman’ tools!”
Craftsman Monster
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“We have a 15-year-old Craftsman ‘Monster Series’ riding mower with a 26-hp. Briggs & Stratton engine, and twin 48-in. decks. It has an automatic transmission, cruise control, and a real nice seat. Every spring we change the oil and filter, replace the spark plugs, and really grease it good. In the fall, we move it into a real dry place for storage after cleaning the deck with an air compressor and spraying rust prevention all over it. The things we’ve replaced are the battery and 2 pairs of blades. We mow 3 acres every season, an airstrip, and a parking area. I’m 90 years old and my wife is 83. Having a great mower like this is important to us.”
Craftsman S6cc
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysDon Baker, Binscarth, Manitoba: Don's happy with his 1993 Craftsman S6cc 16-in. chainsaw. “It performs wonderfully. It always starts good and is easy to keep clean. I haven’t even had to change the spark plug yet after cutting many cords of wood.”
Craftsman SpeedDrive ratcheting screwdriver
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysA Craftsman SpeedDrive ratcheting screwdriver is David’s best buy. “I’ve had five or six drivers of different brands over the years. The one I just bought was an impulse buy. It’s the heaviest one I’ve had. It’s great for quickly putting in or removing screws.”
Craftsman V20 1/2-in drive impact wrench
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysMarc is impressed with his Craftsman V20 1/2-in. drive impact wrench he bought this year. “Since getting it, I haven’t used an air or corded electric impact wrench. It’s powerful, as well as smaller and lighter. The battery lasts a long time before needing a charge.
“My Milwaukee M18 cordless grease gun has made greasing tractors, implements, and vehicles quicker and easier. I haven’t used a handheld lever or pistol grip grease gun since getting the M18. The battery also lasts a long time.”
Marc is disappointed with his Alabama-built Turf Pride G-157 finish mower. A local Kubota dealer sold it. “The mower was purchased new. The belt would crack badly after mowing two to four acres. It came with a Gates industrial V-belt. It had mowed only the grass in the yard. The dealer was of no help in correcting the problem. I fixed it by installing a deck belt for a Skag mower and a softer spring on the idler pulley. Before I fixed it, it had several of the Gates belts.”
Craftsman V5
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysFrancis Deters, Seneca, Kan.: Francis had had bad luck with his Sears Craftsman V5 1/4-in drills and 6 to 7 1/2-in. high speed grinders. “The 1/4-in V5 lasted about two hours; the 3/8-in. about 150 hours before the armature burned out. My four Craftsman high speed grinders each lasted from 18 to 21 hours. Sears sent me a new one and that lasted around 10 hours. It'll be my last one. I'll never even look at a Sears catalogue again. “I always had good luck with Chevrolet trucks. My old 1975 inline 6 cyl. started like a charm and was a real mountain climber. My 1988 Chevy 4.3 liter V-6 gets 24 mpg on dirt roads, 27 mpg on the highway, and 31 mpg with a tailwind, It doesn’t start as well as the inline 6, maybe because the firing order in the V-6 is kind of crazy.”
Craftsman hp aircompressor almost
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysLarry Hudson, Calhoun, Ky.: “I usemy best buy 1980 Craftsman hp aircompressor almost every day for airing up equipment tires and blowing out air filters. I also use it with an air cylinder to bale burley tobacco. The only problem is that the automatic switch doesn’t always work.” Arvin Reu, Luverne, Minn.; Arvin is “very pleased” with his 1979 Chevrolet J80 series Bruin diesel truck. “The 3208 Caterpillar engine has 240,000 miles and still runs good. I'd recommend Caterpillar engines to anyone. “My worst buy was Commence soybean herbicide. It didn’t perform as promised by the salesman and company. It was a waste of time and money.”
Craftsman belt-driven table saw
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyFloyd W. Plank, Rush City, Minn.: “My Stihl FS66 brush cutter is a best buy. I've used it to cut big weeds and small trees up to 2 in. in dia. along fences, around buildings, etc., with no problems. It’s light and easy to service. “My 1991 Craftsman 10-in. belt-driven table saw is a worst buy. None of the guides are perfect so I always have to measure to make sure they’re set right. The blade tends to tilt on its own regardless of how much I adjust the tightener belt.”
Craftsman track drive electric
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysMerrill’s the satisfied owner of a Craftsman 8-hp 26-in. track drive electric start snowblower. “Even though it sat for a year in the carport at the back of my shop, I did nothing but pump the prime bulb and pull the start rope once, and it started and ran perfectly.”
Craftsman utility knife
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My Ford 1220 tractor always starts in the winter. I use glow plugs and never have to plug it in. It always does what I want to do. It gets a lot of loader work and rolls lawns with a homemade 2,900-lb. roller. It blows snow and does some one-furrow plowing. I have a 5-ft. width loader bucket and a 5-ft. snowblower for it. The weight is balanced well for many jobs. The two-speed hydro is always good for the jobs at hand. I added LED lights that really help at night. The 4-WD is fantastic. My only complaint is that it could use a little more power.
“My most recent worst buy is my Craftsman utility knife. It has a retractable blade that always retracts. I have to hold the thumb down on the handle all the time to use it. It doesn’t stay in place. I thought Craftsman would be worthwhile, but I guess not. It has a lifetime warranty, which is easy for the company because it’ll sit on a shelf and not be used, so it should last a lifetime.”
Craftsman commercial lathe
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I usually research the tools I buy ahead of time, so I can’t really say I’ve…”
Craftsman battery-powered backpack sprayers
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“Two of our best buys were Craftsman battery-powered backpack sprayers. One is for weeds, and the other is for livestock. Both work very well.
“The worst things we ever bought were three new Frigidaire refrigerators. Within two years, they were just no good. I’ll never buy another Frigidaire.”
Craftsman fine-tooth flex-head ratchet
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“The handiest ratchet in my toolbox is my 14-in. Craftsman fine-tooth flex-head ratchet. It’s basically a breaker bar with a ratchet head, and with the extra length, it works very well. The fine-tooth gearing makes it more versatile.”
Craftsman riders
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I serviced a Deere 260 riding mower for a friend for 28 years. I’ve used it to pull mowers into my shop. I’ve only changed the oil, filters, etc. Now it’s 38 years old and still going strong.
“I’ve serviced or repaired hundreds of Craftsman riders over the years. Sad to say, they were the most often in need of repairs or were junked.”
Craftsman toolbox
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I bought my Craftsman toolbox and hand tools in 1956 when I was just entering the automotive trade. They’re still going strong after all these years. Whenever I have had a problem with a tool, it was replaced at no charge. Best buy of all time.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.