Chevrolet S10 pickup
What FARM SHOW readers say · 41 Best Buys12 Worst Buys · Trucks & Cars
Chevrolet S10 pickup
41 Best Buys12 Worst Buys“I just got a Hyper Tough electric lawn mower at Walmart. It’s lightweight, cuts well, and the battery lasts longer than I do.
“I bought my Chevy S10 pickup new in 1988. It’s been super reliable, with only normal maintenance needed.”
“I have a 2017 Ford F-150 super cab pickup with a Leer deluxe camper shell on it. This truck has all the power with a V-8 engine and 6-speed transmission. It gets good gas mileage. It’s the most comfortable riding truck I’ve ever owned. I’ve owned several Ford pickups in my lifetime and have had no problems with any of them except a 2004 F-150 that had the air conditioner compressor clutch go out after 14 years and 160,000 miles.
“The worst pickup I ever owned was a Chevy S-10 with the 4.3-liter engine. The battery failed first and then the brakes gave out. The engine lost oil pressure due to a clamp on the oil cooler line which chafed through and leaked the oil out. The dealer replaced the line under warranty, but the engine has used oil ever since the repair. The truck had less than 40,000 miles when I traded it.”
“I’ve had a few standout best buys in my 85 years. I used my 1969 Deere 4020 diesel for 46 years. It never needed motor work; only a clutch and the hydraulic pump fixed.
“My 1955 Ford 860 was used for 60 years with no major problems. It was a safe tractor for my wife and daughters to operate. It had standing room for passengers and was easy to get on and off.
“Finally, my 1999 Chevy S-10 had no major problems in 21 years. With care, it pulled 100-bushel gravity boxes to town.”
“My 1997 Chevrolet S-10 pickup has more than 750,000 miles on it while requiring only basic maintenance and an engine overhaul.
“My 2017 LS 100 hp. tractor has had a lot of problems. The engine overheats after only a few minutes of use, rubber on the tires is peeling off, and there have been many electrical issues. I wouldn’t recommend this tractor to anyone.”
“I own a parking lot striping business and use my 2014 Stihl KM130R Power Broom to remove rocks and debris. It starts and runs easy and saves a lot of shoveling. The Power Broom is just one of several interchangeable attachments I use with the company’s KombiSystem multi-task tool system.
“My two Stihl leaf blowers are so powerful they’ll move 1-in. rocks.
“After just eleven months, the in-tank fuel pump on my 1998 Chevrolet S-10 pickup quit working. The pump was still under warranty, but I had to pay for the labor which was quite costly.
“One reason I love my 1972 Chevrolet K20 4-WD pickup is that the doors have wing vent windows in them. The company should never have gotten rid of them.”
“Our 1990 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 4.3-liter engine has more than 216,000 miles on it but still runs perfect. It doesn’t use any oil, either.”
“My 1993 Chevrolet S-10 pickup always starts and gets more than 20 mpg. It has required only routine maintenance and has never needed a wheel alignment. I recently bought state collector license plates for it.”
“Several years ago I bought a used 1997 Chevrolet S10 pickup to replace a 1990 S10 that my son totaled. I’ve put more than 120,000 miles on it with no major problems. I use it to run back and forth from the house or barn to our fields and to town.
“When the stamped steel axle on my MTD Poulan riding mower broke, I called the dealer only to find out he had died. With no dealers around I called the company asking for a replacement front axle, but all I got was the run-around. So I got my welder out and repaired the axle by myself.”
“About 10 years ago, I bought a 1993 Chevy S-10 pickup with about 175,000 miles. It used one quart of oil about every 200 miles. I started using Lucas heavy-duty oil stabilizer and soon the engine began using less oil (www.lucasoil.com). I add the stabilizer with every oil change, and now the pickup uses only about one quart every 2,500 to 3,000 miles. It has about 266,000 miles on it. We drive it every day.”
“My 1991 and 1995 Chevrolet S-10 pickups both work great and have required only routine maintenance. One has almost 200,000 miles and the other more than 238,000.”
Kenneth nominates his 1994 Chevrolet S-10 pickup as his “best buy”. “It has required only routine maintenance and always runs well, even in the coldest weather. The engine and drivetrain are still in great shape. I thought about trading it in for a Chevrolet Colorado, but the S10 is more fuel efficient.”
“With nearly 450,000 miles on it, my Chevy S-10 has been a real best buy. It’s always been driven pedal to the floor and has traveled from Alaska to Mexico and east to Minn.
“Real mileage is probably closer to 500,000, as I replaced the original 14-in. rims with 15-in. rims and bigger tires at 130,000 miles. I’ve replaced a few things like the front coil springs and rear leaf springs, brake rotors and drums, all at 300,000. I’m currently on my fourth transmission.
“At 332,000 miles, I had the engine rebuilt from a 2.8 L to a 3.1 with a longer stroke. That bumped mileage by about 2 mpg.
“It’s a tough truck. I once drove it for 70 miles with the engine full of coolant before I discovered the problem. I flushed it with diesel and put it back together. I had planned to change the oil and filter again a few days later, but added another 3,000 miles before doing so. Oil change intervals have varied from 3,000 to many as 12,000 miles,
“It has packed heavy loads over the years to the point where the rear axle bottomed out on the bumper stops. Yet most of the front-end joints are original with only a few items replaced.
“After hitting several deer, I made a ‘deer bumper’ for the truck out of about $900 of heavy aluminum pipe and steel plate.”
“I still drive it every day,” says Marvin, owner of a 1988 Chevrolet S-10 pickup with more than 475,000 miles on it. “It’s equipped with a 4.3-liter engine and 704 transmission, and the drivetrain has never been touched. I’ve always done my own service work.
“My 1975 Cub Cadet 1650 garden tractor is a best buy. It’s still going strong and I use it to mow more than three acres of grass. I’m 75 years young and still on-the-go.”
“I’m impressed with my 1998 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 4-cyl. engine and 5-speed transmission. It gets more than 30 mpg on the highway and about 27 mpg with general driving. This pickup has more than 148,000 miles on it but still runs great and has been trouble-free. It has plenty of power and is a far better pickup than the Ford Rangers I’ve owned in the past. Also, it has a comfortable seat.”
On the minus side, he lists his Maytag stove and refrigerator. “This company used to be known for its high quality products, but in my opinion that quality isn’t there any more. The refrigerator freezes our produce, yet where I keep milk on the top shelf it’s 40 degrees. I have to turn up the freezer thermostat all the way in order to keep ice cream hard. The refrigerator has required many service calls.”
“I’m pleased with my 2000 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 2.2-liter, 4-cyl. engine and manual shift transmission. It’s a ‘flex fuel’ pickup, and I get about 22 to 23 mpg on short trips and up to 28 mpg on longer trips. I don’t need a $35,000 pickup just to run to town to get parts, so it’s great for what we use it for. I use E-85 gas in it most of the time.”
On the negative side, “We’ve built four Lester buildings over the years, but the last building I put up in 1993 is my worst buy ever. The glue in the particle board isn’t any good so the outside just falls apart. It has a 15-year warranty and I’ve called the company but with no success. They blame it on the company that made the material, Louisiana Pacific. Apparently, Lesters won a lawsuit against Louisiana Pacific for $59 million. But my warranty is with Lesters and it doesn’t say anything about Louisiana Pacific. I just want the building fixed.”
“I bought my 1984 Chevrolet S10 pickup used more than 10 years ago. It now has about 400,000 miles on it but is still going strong. We use it to haul feed, as well as sheep and lambs. We call this pickup our ‘gray ghost’ because it refuses to die.”
“My 2004 Kubota mower is a rugged piece of equipment. I bought it new last spring and as of late November it already had more than 1,000 hours on it. I use it with a Hayban trail mower that offsets to the side of the Kubota, resulting in an 84-in. wide cut.
“My 1997 Chevrolet S10 pickup is my
Contact: FARM SHOW Followup, Roger Zummach, 62746 110th St., Hutchinson, Minn. 55350 (ph 320 587-3572). worst buy. The engine lacks power and had to be repaired three times.”
“My 1999 Chevrolet S-10 pickup is my worst buy. The tailgate cables on it broke and our dealer wouldn’t replace them. Neither would the company. The dealer said it was a maintenance problem. “
“My 1991 Chevrolet S10 pickup has more than 270,000 miles on it but is still going strong. No problems.
“My 2000 DR push trimmer equipped with a 6 hp engine is my worst buy. It doesn’t work nearly as well as advertised. Parts on it continually break, including string heads and height spacers, etc. My wife wanted the trimmer because it’s supposed to be easy to use, but she can’t even use it at all. Even I have trouble keeping it running straight. It sure wasn’t worth the $900 I spent on it.”
Norman’s happy with his 1991 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 2.8-liter, V-6 engine. “This pickup has more than 237,000 miles on it. I’ve used it to haul large loads of firewood and to haul produce from Alabama to Michigan and back. I’ve also used it to pull a 17-ft. boat trailer, and have done numerous other chores with it. It has never needed a front-end alignment, and the engine still doesn’t use any oil. It gets 33 mpg on trips pulling a load. The only repairs I’ve had to make were to replace a clutch and a water pump.”
“I like my Deere 335 garden tractor equipped with a 48-in. deck. I put more than 600 hours on it last year with no major problems. I like the power steering and hydraulic lift. I also like the cruise control. We used it to mow 13 cemetaries and 123 yards. I think Deere makes the best mowers for this kind of work.
“My worst buy was a Chevrolet S10 pickup equipped with an extended cab and fully loaded. In 7,000 miles it was in the shop seven times for problems with the EGR valve and exhaust sensors. I couldn’t get anyone to fix it so at 7,700 miles I traded it off.
“Our 2000 Dodge Dakota Quad Cab 4-door pickup is a best buy. It’s a lot better truck than the Chevrolet S-10 pickup we owned before. The Dodge has been in the shop only once and that was for a very minor adjustment.”
“My 1991 GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 350 cu. in., V-8 engine is my best buy. It runs great and I haven’t had any problems with it. It has plenty of power to haul my livestock trailer.
“My 1987 Chevrolet S-10 pickup runs great and is also a best buy.”
“My best buy is my Sears Craftsman Speed-Lok set for drill bits, screwdrivers, and nut drivers. It lets me change heads in only a few seconds and is a real time-saver.
“I like my 1994 Chevrolet S-10 pickup, except for one problem. The automatic transmission doesn’t always shift up like it should without racing the engine. I’ve taken it to two different shops and changed the transmission oil and even flushed the transmission, but this problem still occasionally happens. It doesn’t make any difference what the outside temperature is. If anyone has a solution I’d like to hear from them (P.O. Box 175, Moundridge, Kan. 67107 ph 316 345-8674).”
Harry’s the happy owner of a 1999 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 5-speed transmission with overdrive. “It gets 28 to 30 mpg and has required only routine maintenance. I always change the oil every 3,000 to 4,000 miles. It has 11,000 miles on it.”
“My worst buy is my 1994 Chevrolet S-10 pickup. At 43,000 miles the transmission had to be rebuilt and a new ring gear installed, at a cost of $1,700. The warranty didn’t cover anything because it expired after 36,000 miles.”
R.W.’s happy with the Chevy S-10 longbed pickup that he bought new in 1996.
“It’s a good little pickup. I’ve put 11,000 miles on it with no problems,” he says. “I bought it because I had a 1986 S-10 I put 126,000 miles on with absolutely no expenses.”
“My 1995 Chevrolet S-10 extended cab pickup is the best I’ve ever owned. It has 31,000 trouble-free miles. The 4.3-liter, 200 hp Vortec engine is very responsive and gets 22 to 24 mpg on the highway which I think is very good for a 4-WD. “I have a 1951 Deere A tractor that I bought 25 years ago and it still runs great. I think that with a little tender loving care these old tractors would last forever.”
Bruce gives a “thumbs down” on his 1993 Chevrolet S-10 pickup. “The engine blew up, the power steering pump went out, and a steering bracket broke - all this in a span of only 1 1/2 years.”
“My best buy ever is a 1985 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 2.5-liter 4-cyl. engine and 5-speed transmission. It has 237,000 miles and is still going strong. It’s easy on fuel and doesn’t use any oil.”
“My 1995 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 4-cyl. engine is neither a best nor a worst buy. Sometimes the engine will idle at a high 2,800 rpm’s and won’t drop back to normal idle speed until I start driving. I often have to drive at least 10 miles before it works properly. Another problem is that the engine makes a peculiar rattling sound whenever it operates at a certain rpm. The dealer hasn’t been able to find out why it idles fast and the company won’t help. The pickup does have a very comfortable cab and excellent fuel economy.”
“My 1991 Belarus 825 tractor equipped with a Leon front-end loader is my best buy. It took some time to get used to the gearshift pattern and I had to have a number of O ring seals replaced, but now I think it’s a great tractor for the money. After five years of use it doesn’t owe me a lot. “I like my 1995 Suzuki LT 4-WD ATV. I use it a lot for spot spraying. “I had a bad experience with a 1994 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. engine. The engine had to be replaced at 72,000 miles and I eventually traded the pickup off for a Chevrolet 2500 model. The dealer eventually fixed things under my extended warranty but he never had parts on hand. I think dealers should always have a few basic parts on hand, not just spark plugs and filters.”
Last year Kenneth bought a used 1987 Chevrolet S-10 extended cab 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6-cyl. 2.8-liter engine and 5-speed transmission. It’s his “best buy”. “It had 115,000 miles on it when I bought it and I’ve used it for about six months so far with no problems. It doesn’t use any oil or show any major wear anywhere. The front end alignment is still good, it has a tight body, the doors fit well, and all the controls work. It gets 21 mpg.”
3960 chopper which he bought used, "Even when we put two windrows together the machine is still hungry. It has reduced our chopping time by half or more “My Stihl chain saw is a best buy. It's sull going strong after 18 years. I've used it to cut 14 cords of wood a year to heat our house, as well as to cut lumber and pulp.” Tom Tate, Sublimity, Ore.: “My 1980 Bush Hog heavy duty (5-ft. tandem disk does a good job of penctrating our heavy grass seed sod due to the weight on cach disc blade. It does as good a job as an offset disk, and by swinging the gangs backward I can reduce the angle of the blades so can use it to do finish work. It's well built. “My 1987 Chevrolet S-10 4-WD pickup, which bought used with all the ‘bells and whistles’, is my worst buy, The V-6 engine is hard on fuel, and reverse gear on the automatic transmission failed immediately. The transfer case leaks as does the transmission. I've had nothing but trouble with the gauges - the oil pressure sensor has been replaced three times and now it's out again. Also, the transfer case shift has broken the gear shift linkage twice.”
Harold Sikma, St. Anne, IIL: Harold nominates his 1992 Chevrolet S-10 long bed pickup equipped with a 2.8-liter 6-cyl. engine and 5-speed manual transmission as his “best buy”. “It’s easy on fuel and has been reliable over 33,000 miles. It’s a solid pickup with a good ride. I also liked my 1984 Chevrolet S-10 which I drove until it had 87,000 miles.”
Steve Hoke, Walkersville, Md.: “My worst buy is my Chevrolet S-10 Blazer. The dealer-installed 5-speed manual transmission lasted only about 9,000 miles. When I tried to find out why it went out with so few miles on it, all I got from the company was lip service. My Blazer is now on its second engine and third transmission. Why can’t we buy quality-made products in this country? If I'd have bought a Landrover I'd have spent about the same money, but I'd have paid it up front instead of being nickeled and dimed to death because of inferior parts.”
W.F. Blackman, Dothan, Ala.: “Our 1988 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 4.3 liter V-6 engine has plenty of power and is fuel efficient. It’s nimble in traffic, too.”
Herb Cressler, Hoxie, Kan: “A 1989 Chevrolet S-10 pickup that bought in 1992 with 2,100 miles on it is one of my best buys. I had problems with the brake module and paint peeling, but Chevy took care of the problems under warranty.”
Calvin Bloom, Mount Airy, Md.: Calvin's worst buy is the Chevrolet S-10 4-WD Blazer he bought new in 1992. “It had no brake pads left at all after less than a year. After many trips to the garage - and contacting the Better Business Bureau in our area - Chevrolet traded us for a 1993 Blazer that soon developed the same prob lem, That one had only 5% rear brake pads left, as was proven by the local dealer’s service manager as well as a representative from Chevy. The service manager told he was getting several Blazers in per month with the same problem and couldn't fix it, We finally gave up and traded the Blazer off.”
R.W. Tegtmeier, Sumner, Iowa: “My IH 1640 combine is super. It runs great in corn and puts nothing but clean grain in the tank. I'm also pleased with my 1986 Chevrolet S-10 pickup. It has over 100,000 miles on it and uses no oil. The engine has never needed any repairs.”
Steve Weisbrod, Canastota, N.Y.: A 1994 Chevrolet S-10 extended cab pickup equipped with a 200 hp 6-cyl. engine rates as Steve's “best buy”. “It’s built strong and has a quiet, comfortable ride. Even with the high output 6-cyl. engine it gets 21 mpg. The computer-controlled 4-speed automatic transmission shifts smooth and is always working in the right gear. “My Deere electronic moisture tester is my worst biy. The first one I bought failed after a couple of years, and the second one produces very erratic readings in wheat.”
Earl Zeltwangen, Wyatt, Ind.: Earl nominates his new Chevrolet S-10 4-WD extended cab pickup as “best buy”. “It runs smooth, is easy on fuel, and the 4-WD works good. I really like it. “We extended our shop with a 50-fl. Butler all-steel building and like ita lot, It’s completely insulated. We also installed a Shenandoah waste oil burning heater that works good. I’m a dealer for it.”
Lawrence Brenner, San Felipe, Texas: “My 1990 Dodge Dakota pickup is my best buy. It's been trouble-free except for the air conditioning. Handles well and rides comfortably. It carries a bigger payload than a Chevrolet S-10, Toyota, or other pickup brands.”
Deborah McCollum, Lockport, N.Y.: “Our New Holland 855 round baler has a lot of capacity which, combined with autowrap, makes baling hay quick and casy even in a bad year. “Our worst buy is our 1992 Chevrolet S10 pickup equipped with a 2.5-liter 4-cyl. engine. Ithas had hesitation problems from the startand, when itrains, water comes into the cab through the vents.”
Fred Hoag, Niles, Mich.: “My 1991 Chevrolet S-10 pickup performs well. It’s my best buy.”
Ronald J. Swank, Bellville, Ohio: “I’ve had good luck with my 1992 Skil 2503 cordless drill. It has plenty of power and the charge lasts much longer than expected, It’s also lightweight which makes it easy to handle even in awkward positions, “My 1985 Chevrolet S-10 pickup is also “My 14-year-old son hopes that I'm ready to buy a new pickup in two years so he can have this one.” a best buy. It’s equipped with a 4-speed transmission and 2.8-liter V-6 engine that has plenty of power to pull a 1,500 Ib. load. It’s trouble-free and fun to drive. My 14year old son hopes that I'm ready to buy a new pickup in two years so he can have this one.” “My Sears Craftsman 3/8-in. drive ratchet is my worst buy. The ratchet gear broke so I took it back to the company. Instead of replacing the ratchet they gave me a rebuild kit with parts made so poor that once they were installed, the ratchet wouldn't work.”
Lavon Lampkin, Arkansas City, Ark.: “My 1989 Chevrolet S-10 pickup was a real lemon. At times it idled too high at 2,500 rpms, and I couldn't get it to slow down, The throwout bearing and rear end made constant noise. I made countless trips to the dealer who told me there was nothing he could do. traded it in on a 1990 Dodge pickup which works great. I think GM has lost pride in its products. “My Case-IH 1680 combine is a best buy. It cuts rice smooth and fast and does an excellent job of threshing and cleaning all crops. No problems at all.”
Larry H. Lampe, Hillsboro, Iowa: “My Yamaha Terra-Pro 350 ATY isa real workhorse. I use itevery day for chores. I’ve also used it to pull an 8-row sprayer over 800 acres. No downtime or repairs.” Roy Westendorff, Pewamo, Mich.; “It has over 12,000 miles and gets about the same gas mileage as advertised,” says Roy, happy with his 1991 Chevrolet S-10 pickup equipped with a 4-cylinder engine, Best & Wo ( can’ tbelieve how many acres iLcan cover in a day.” Maynard's had trouble with a Razor Cat sickle and guards, manufactured by Herschel Mfg. Co., which he installed on his New Holland haybine. “It wouldn't cut brome grass at 3 mph. The sickle pulled so hard that it tore the wobble box and bracket into two pieces. The machine was destroyed because it had unibody construction.”
Steven Ortner, Wakeman, Ohio: “My 1989 Chevrolet S-10 Blazer 4 by 4 is definitely one of the best purchases I've ever made,” says Steven. “It drives great and rides like a dream. The 4.3 liter V-6 engine has plenty of power and sull gets 20 mpg. The shift-on-the-fly 4-WD is probably the nicest feature. It’s rated to tow 5,000 Ibs. sustained.”
Donald Hoffart, Plainview, Neb.: Donald has had bad luck with his 1988 Chevrolet S10 pickup. “It idled so fast I could hardly drive it. Something went wrong about every 1,000 miles. The dealer has been working on the pickup about three times a month for the past six months, but it’s still no good, General Motors won't replace it.”
Joseph Fara, Schoolcraft, Mich.: “My 1983 Chevrolet S-10 is the best pickup I’ve ever owned and over the years I’ve owned a GMC, two Dodges, two Fords, two Datsuns, and three Chevrolets. The Chevrolets have consistently been the besttrucks. The S-10 has 90,000 miles on it and is still going strong. It doesn'tuse any oil, has no rust, gets 20 mpg on short trips and 25 mpg over the road. I also pull a 16-ft. travel trailer with the truck with no problems. One thing it needs is a heavier clutch.” R.C. Vonarx, Courtenay, British Columbia: “Our Vicon KM281 disc mower/conditioner does a good job and has high capacity. Daily maintenance is low and we know from neighbors, that it'll last a long time. “We're also pleased with our Deere 2550 tractor. Works great with a loader on it.” Edwin C. Lounsberry, Jacksonville, Ill: “We've used our 1987 Deere 318 lawn and garden tractor most every day for over a year with no problems. The dealer was willing to take our old garden tractor in trade.” Howard R. Johnson, Vermillion, S. Dak.: “My 1968 International 856 tractor is onc of my all-time best buys. Ithas all the power I need and I’ve had no major problems with itin nearly 6,000 hrs. Itjust keeps rolling along.”
Kent Krause, Adams, Neb.: “My 1983 4-WD Chevrolet S-10 pickup with a V-6 and 4-speed manual transmission should JO. |] #£x§€ ARM GHOW «e 13 only have been driven on pavement. It wasn’t made for off-road work,” says Kent about his “worst buy”. “It’s geared too fast in first and reverse. First was too fast for travel over a rough pasture and it takes a lot of skill to back it up a hill or in loose ground without killing the engine. A stick or cornstalk can easily knock off the plastic hub caps. The box is lightweight and easily dented, The front fenders are too narrow so that mud flies up and lands in your lap if the window is open and there is across wind, In mud, when you notice a loss of power, you have to get out and dig the mud out of the end of the exhaust pipe. At29,000 miles I had to replace the expensive front drivehsaft C.V. joints.” On the positive side, “Our 1987 Case/IH 1660 combine threshes well and cleans grain with little damage. A very nice, clean quiet cab.”
Craig Davis, Connell, Wash.: “My 1984 Chevrolet S-10 pickup needed a complete $1,100 transmission rebuild at 35,000 miles. It was then back for lesser transmission problems 10,000 miles later. It doesn’t have enough power to handle the 4speed automatic transmission, Fuel mileage is also disappointing.” He’s happier with his 1986 Logan selfunloading truck bed. ‘“Trouble-free and actually works as advertised.”
Bob Fuhs, Ft. Branch, Ind.: He likes his 1983 Chevrolet S-10 4-WD pickup. “I've had it for almost a year and drive it seven days a week. I haven't had a single problem with the truck nor have I taken it back to the dealer for any service. It rides good and drives excellent. The V-6 engine gets great mileage and has good power."
Own a Chevrolet? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.
Your report could appear in a future issue.