Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Coleman

Coleman: what farmers say

15 reports in FARM SHOW · 6 Best Buys9 Worst Buys

Coleman 10 hp 5

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Thomas Spurliwg, Ft. Lypton, Colo. · Vol. 23, No. 2 (1999), p. 16

Thomas is unhappy with his new Coleman 10 hp 5,000-watt generator. “The output voltage is determined by the engine rpm’s. The owner’s manual, which was missing, stated the voltage was factory-set. And it was. After I purchased a volt meter, I discovered the voltage was set at 135. I’d think Coleman could at least include a volt meter with the generator for little or no extra cost.”

Best Buy
Thomas Spurling, Ft. Lupton, Colo. · Vol. 23, No. 1 (1999), p. 16

“I’m not too pleased with my new Coleman 10 hp, 5,000-watt generator. The output voltage of the generator is determined by engine rpm’s. The company manual - which we never got - stated that the output voltage was factory set. It sure was - at 135 volts. The generator doesn’t have a volt meter on it so I had to purchase a volt meter in order to find out what the voltage was.

“I’m well pleased with my 1992 Deere 2355 utility tractor which replaced my previous Deere 730 model. The 2355 has a lot of power and is fuel efficient and easy to service. The only problem I’ve had is when I back up and use the clutch at the same time -the seat doesn’t swivel and the 3-pt. lever is mounted too low to be reached conveniently when backing up.”

Coleman 18-volt cordless drill

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
Randy Kuehn, Enumclaw, Wash. · Vol. 35, No. 5 (2011), p. 15

Randy likes his Silky Hayauchi aluminum telescoping pole saw (ph 866 345-2468; www.silkysaws.com). “It reaches out up to 21 ft. so I can prune a lot of trees without having to climb them. It extends and retracts like a surgical tool. I’ve used it on a lot of trees, but it still cuts great.

“My Coleman 18-volt cordless drill came with two batteries. One of them never worked, and the other one lacked power.”

Worst Buy
Cliff De Boom, Custer, Wash. · Vol. 29, No. 6 (2005), p. 13

Cliff nominates his 2002 Coleman 18-volt drill as his “worst buy”. “The battery died after only 16 months of use. The drill cost just $29 but a replacement battery would have cost $79. The problem is that they’re using a 24-volt charger on an 18-volt battery.”

Coleman Powermate generator

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
Dennis R. Fuqua, Seiling, Okla. · Vol. 26, No. 3 (2002), p. 16

Dennis says he’s happy with his 2001 Coleman Powermate generator. “It starts easy and has a lot of power. It’ll easily operate a 1/2-in. drill.

“My worst buy is the pipe leveler I bought from Northern Tool & Equipment. I can’t get it to work right. It’s poorly made.”

Worst Buy
Stanley Knipfer, Webster, Iowa · Vol. 22, No. 2 (1998), p. 16

Stanley’s had problems with his Coleman Powermate air compressor equipped with a 4 1/2 hp motor and 25-gal. tank. “The motor isn’t big enough to start the pump in cold weather. However, it works fine in temperatures above 60 degrees.”

Coleman 400 UTV

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Dave Lash, Mc Donald, Penn. · Vol. 49, No. 2 (2025), p. 15

Dave’s worst buy is his 2021 Coleman 400 UTV. “After buying it new from Tractor Supply, I started having trouble shifting. I contacted T.S., and they told me to contact Coleman directly. I told them I was still using it on the farm, and they said that was fine. Then I lost the reverse completely, and they found a repair shop near me where I should take it. This establishment was very good to work with. They found that the transmission needed to be replaced. It took three months to arrive. It worked for a while, but it’s still not right.”

Coleman 5 000-watt generator

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Gene Meyer, Clintonville, Wis. · Vol. 30, No. 2 (2006), p. 13

“My 1997 Ford F-250 4-WD diesel pickup equipped with a 7.3-liter diesel engine is my best buy. My wife and I have a performance horse business, and she runs the rodeo circuit on a pro level. I’ve tried using different makes and models of pickups to pull our 3 and 4-horse trailer equipped with living quarters, but this pickup has the best pulling power and is also fuel efficient.”

On the negative side, “My Coleman 5,000-watt generator is extremely loud and the off switch is defective. It starts hard, but the worst problem is that I need ear muffs to work around it. I give a thumbs down for this machine.”

Coleman 7 000-watt generator

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
John Hill, Millington, Md. · Vol. 23, No. 6 (1999), p. 15

“It’s the best vehicle I’ve ever owned,” says John about his 1985 GM S-15 pickup which has more than 216,000 miles on it. “I’ve never replaced a front end part on it and it doesn’t cut tires like new Ford pickups do. It’s powered by a factory-installed 2.2-liter diesel engine. I park it in the same place every day on a concrete floor and there are no oil stains there at all. It doesn’t leak or burn oil. I can’t understand why the EPA doesn’t require more diesel engines in vehicles. They’re twice as fuel efficient as gas engines, and under Maryland emissions tests they’re considered non-polluting.

“My worst buy is my Coleman 7,000-watt generator which I bought a few years ago. For years it sat in my garage waiting for the time when I would really need it. Well, Hurricane Floyd came along and I really needed it. However, it ran only for about nine hours before it stopped working. I took it apart and found that the plastic cover that housed the end bearing had melted. I called the company and they said they still use this same plastic housing on their new generators. I wonder if the company’s engineers have ever had to depend on this generator the way I did.”

Coleman BT200X minibike

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Jason Pichotta, Crittenden, Ky. · Vol. 47, No. 6 (2023), p. 14

“I bought a Coleman BT200X minibike from Tractor Supply for cheap transportation. TS matched an online price. I’m 46 years old, and I bought it to make quick trips out to the barn or get the mail in a flash. I can be out to the barn in 10 seconds to check on the animals, stop by and get the mail, and be back in a minute. I should’ve bought one years ago.

“My Camco RV water hose didn’t last and had a bad warranty. Even though it was UV protected, it faded, stained, and split.”

Coleman Charger rechargeable flashlight

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Mike Johnson, Montrose, Colo. · Vol. 27, No. 3 (2003), p. 15

Mike says his Coleman Charger rechargeable flashlight is his “best buy”. He uses both a 90 and a 60 model. “I keep one of these lights plugged in at all times in our living room, master bedroom, shop, and barn. They’re always ready to provide up to two hours of bright, continuous light. The 60 model is smaller but has all the 90 model’s features except it has a smaller beam and slightly shorter run-time. A couple of my Coleman flashlights are more than five years old but are still going strong. The newest one was added to our barn just a few months ago.”

On the negative side, he lists his Ryobi reciprocating saw. “I was using it with a 9-in. blade to cut off the top of a 6 by 6 treated barn pole when the saw started smoking and then quit working. I think it should have had an overload protection device of some kind.”

Coleman Powermate 5 hp vertical air

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Larry A. Bauer, Brighton, Colo. · Vol. 20, No. 5 (1996), p. 15

He’s disappointed with his 1996 Coleman Powermate 5 hp 80-gal. vertical air compressor. “It had a valve plate gasket that was blown before I ever used it. It took more than a month to get replacement parts, and I had them installed by a service technician. However, as soon as I started the compressor up the gasket blew again. I called the company several times to no avail. After two months I traded it in for a second unit which also failed to start due to an improper pop-off valve. I’ll never buy another product from this company again.” On the “best buy” side, “My 1995 GateWay 2000 desktop personal computer is easy to set up and the operator’s manual is clear and well-written. It has worked great right from the start.”

Coleman air compressor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Scott Wolf, Ramona, S. Dak. · Vol. 42, No. 3 (2018), p. 15

“I bought an 11-gal. Coleman air compressor from Menards, and after just one year it blew up. I then bought a 15-gal. Coleman stand-up compressor and it blew up after one year, too. I called the company but they told me this is a throw-away world, and that I should just buy another one. So I did, only this time I bought a Masterforce model. I love it.”

Coleman cordless drill

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Jim Wicks, Sr., Lewiston, Idaho · Vol. 30, No. 1 (2006), p. 14

A Bosch 5-in. angle grinder rates as Jim’s “best buy”. “It has good balance and a lot of power for its size. I like the way it feels in my hands, and I also like the type of switch it has. When you turn the switch on the tool stays on, and when you turn it off it goes off.

“The Coleman cordless drill I bought at Home Depot is my worst buy. From the beginning it lacked power, and the battery wouldn’t hold a charge. I could drive only about three 2-in. screws before the battery gave out. Then I had to put the battery on the charger for an hour just so that I could drive another three screws. It was very frustrating.”

Coleman generator

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Lanny Vail, Bowman, N. Dak. · Vol. 41, No. 6 (2017), p. 15

“The gas-powered Massey Ferguson 165 tractor I bought used 30 years ago is my best buy. It spent its early days pulling a pto-driven small square baler for a local custom haying operation. I was on the road a lot with it so I replaced the rear tires with Firestone Field and Road tires. I also had to replace an oil seal on the pto shaft. Otherwise the tractor has required only routine maintenance. Now I use it mostly in the winter for blowing snow, and it always starts right up.”

On the negative side, “I had less than seven hours on my Coleman generator when something on it flew apart causing it to stop working. The warranty had expired just 7 days before, so I thought maybe the company would help out. No luck. If the company rep I talked to hadn’t been so nasty, I would have accepted that the generator was out of warranty and just junked it. But now I’ll never buy a Coleman product again or recommend them to anyone else.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW