Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Caterpillar

Caterpillar: what farmers say

34 reports in FARM SHOW · 27 Best Buys7 Worst Buys

Caterpillar Challenger

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Shelby Britten, Haswell, Colo. · Vol. 24, No. 6 (2000), p. 14

“Our three Caterpillar Challenger 85E’s have performed great and are best buys. We had a few minor problems which were covered under warranty by the dealer. These tractors have plenty of lugging power and traction and perform even better than our previous 85C tractors.

“We consistently have had problems with our two Yamaha Warrior 4-wheeler ATV’s. When we brought them home, one of them kept cutting out at high end. We weren’t able to trade it off. The second model started doing the same thing. After spending $1,000 on parts we still haven’t solved the problem.”

Best Buy
Allen Snodgrass, Vandalia, Mo. · Vol. 22, No. 1 (1998), p. 14

“My 1997 Deere 9300 4-WD tractor equipped with a powershift transmission is my worst buy. Every time I push on the clutch the transmission automatically goes to first gear, so I have to shift through all the gears to get to the gear I want. The tractor is equipped with the weights and tire size and pressure recommended by the company, yet ‘wheel hop’ is so bad I often have to stop, which puts the transmission back into first gear again. Another problem is that it shifts rough and jumps and jerks terribly. It had just 28 hours on it when I traded it for a Caterpillar Challenger. The Cat is a nice tractor to operate.” He’s impressed with his 1996 Dodge 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine and 5-speed transmission. “It has a lot of power and gets 22 mpg on the highway and 14 to 15 mpg pulling a trailer, and it doesn’t use any oil. It rides nice for a 3/4-ton pickup and is a pleasure to drive.”

Worst Buy
Thomas R. Harper, Simpson, Sask. · Vol. 22, No. 6 (1998), p. 15

“The poor customer service I received for what is otherwise a nice machine is a disgrace,” says Thomas who’s had trouble getting help with an air conditioning problem in a Caterpillar Challenger 75 that he bought in 1994.

“The first summer the air conditioning worked poorly. The dealer said the system was not cycling properly and would require a company-rebuilt unit. I managed to keep the air conditioning going over the next three summers while I tried to get the company to fix the problem. Last April, the company again said it would send someone out, but, as of October, the problem still hadn’t been fixed.”

Best Buy
K. Kirkham, Sexsmith, Alberta · Vol. 21, No. 2 (1997), p. 16

“Our Caterpillar Challenger 75 tractor is the best all-around tractor we’ve ever owned. It’s easy on fuel, has a comfortable ride, a lot of power, and tracks that don’t slip. Works great for plowing snow, too.”

Caterpillar D5B SA crawler tractor

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Michael Zimmerman, Versailles, Mo. · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 12

Michael is pleased with his 1980 Caterpillar D5B SA crawler tractor. “We replaced the whole undercarriage with all new parts and also installed a 540 and 1,000 rpm pto off a White 2-150 wheel tractor. In addition, we replaced the original fuel injection pump with an Interim Scroll Fuel injection pump off a Caterpillar D7G, set at 200 hp. A bigger manifold and turbocharger helps engine exhaust temperature to run cooler. The changes helped boost engine horsepower from 165 to 200 hp.

“This crawler works great to pull a 7-shank Sunflower deep ripper 14 in. deep. It has a 6-speed and hydraulic steering. It’ll outperform any 4-WD wheeled tractor doing tillage work and burn less fuel, with less soil compaction and very little slippage. It also rides better in the field than wheeled tractors. We have two of these on our farm and are well-pleased with them.”

Feature storyBest Buy
A FARM SHOW reader · Vol. 35, No. 6 (2011), p. 13 · Full story at FARM SHOW →

Michael Zimmerman, Zimmerman Tractor, Versailles, Mo., is pleased with his 1981 Caterpillar D5BSA crawler tractor which he modified to power pto-operated equipment.

Read the whole story →

Caterpillar 04C bulldozer

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Ike Mast, Millersburg, Ohio · Vol. 30, No. 4 (2006), p. 15

“My new Caterpillar 04C bulldozer is my worst buy. I had problems with the water pump which had a broken weld; the steering clutch wasn’t upgraded by the company as it was supposed to be; the parts book wasn’t upgraded; a piece of emery cloth was found in the oil pan; and the engine uses a lot of oil and tends to overheat. The warranty service has been very poor.”

Caterpillar 1160 V-8 225 hp

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Clark Dysle, Scio, Ore. · Vol. 21, No. 1 (1997), p. 15

“I installed a Caterpillar 1160 V-8, 225 hp remanufactured engine in my 10-yard dump truck. It starts easy, has a lot of power, is fuel efficient, and easy to maintain. “My 1987 Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a diesel engine is my worst buy. The pickup runs good but has a hydraulic clutch that’s poorly engineered. The master and slave cylinders are made from plastic and wear out about every 50,000 miles. It costs about $200 to replace them. Perhaps a system could be designed that uses hydraulic pressure from the power steering system. Why not go back to metal cylinders with stainless steel liners?”

Caterpillar 236 skid loader

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gene Pearson, Wichita, Kansas · Vol. 28, No. 2 (2004), p. 13

A 2001 Caterpillar 236 skid loader rates as Gene’s “best buy.” “It runs smooth and has plenty of power for doing small jobs. If it ever gets overloaded it diverts hydraulic pressure to avoid damaging the machine.

“I bought a used 1999 Ford F-350 crew cab pickup with 353,000 miles. I’ve put about 10,000 miles on it and it hasn’t used any oil.

“My 1997 Daewoo DSL 801 skid loader is my worst buy. It’s not a bad machine in most respects, but there’s absolutely no dealer support or parts availability. I replaced it with a Caterpillar 236 skid loader and am pleased with it.”

Caterpillar 236B3 skid loader

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Mervin Mast, Charlotte, Mich. · Vol. 43, No. 4 (2019), p. 15

Mervin’s impressed with his 2019 Milwaukee 18-volt hammer drill/driver kit. “I recently used it with a hole saw to drill 4-in. dia. holes through 1 1/2-in. thick lumber, and it exceeded my expectations. This tool has a lot of power and torque for a variety of applications.

“My 2012 Caterpillar 236B3 skid loader has plenty of power and is handy for many jobs around the farm.”

Caterpillar 242 skid steer loader

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Bruce Stumlin, Holmen, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 4 (2005), p. 15

“My worst buy is my 2003 Caterpillar 242 skid steer loader which I bought from Fabco Industries, LaCrosse, Wis. They can’t fix it and refuse to replace it with a working machine. The first year I used it I had to return it to the dealer several times, as the hydraulics didn’t work properly. I can’t control the movement of the bucket. As a result it will drop, not holding the position required. Also, whenever I release the joystick I never know if the wheels will stop right away or continue to turn some.”

Caterpillar 246 skid steer loader

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Alan M. Tierney, Capron, Ill. · Vol. 34, No. 4 (2010), p. 14

Alan nominates his 2000 Caterpillar 246 skid steer loader as his “worst buy”. “It has 1,058 hours on it. The oil pump housing broke and went completely through the engine, ruining it. It cost more than $8,000 to fix. There has been one problem after another. I’d never recommend this skid steer to anyone.”

Caterpillar 246 Turbo

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Alan M. Tierney, Capron, Ill. · Vol. 33, No. 4 (2009), p. 14

“In 2000 my brother Daryl and I bought a Caterpillar 246 Turbo A Series skid loader. It’s equipped with a cab and heater but the heater has never worked. At 238 hours the right side hydraulic motor went out. At 1,555 hours the oil pump housing broke off, ruining the motor. The company wanted $20,000 to repair it, but after three months of fighting we ended up paying $4,753 for the repairs.

“My brother and I are the only ones who operate this machine so it’s not abused. It’s powered by a poorly designed Perkins/Caterpillar diesel engine. After 8 years of use and with only a little more than 3,000 hours on it, I’m not impressed. Not with an industrial piece of equipment doing hobby farm work. So much for Caterpillar dependability and resale.”

Caterpillar 262 B skid loader

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
W. H. Bauer, Port Lavaca, Texas · Vol. 40, No. 5 (2016), p. 14

“My worst buy happened 10 years ago when I spent $47,000 for a Caterpillar 262 B skid loader. Mechanically, the machine is fine. The problem is with the air conditioner. It couldn’t even cool the cab. A year after I bought it the dealer said he could make it work, so I spent $1,200 for repairs but it still doesn’t work.

“I use this machine to operate a tree shear and an Ammbusher rotary brush cutter. It has very low hours since I can only use it during winter when it’s cool outside. When I bought my next skid loader I didn’t even consider Cat.”

Caterpillar 3116 diesel engine

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
David Cornea, Morse, Sask. · Vol. 24, No. 2 (2000), p. 14

David’s very disappointed with his 1997 General Motors C-60 (Topkick) semi truck equipped with a Caterpillar 3116 diesel engine. He received the truck in April, 1999, over a year after ordering it. “After I got it, everything worked okay until winter arrived. Then the engine ran terrible, with enough blueish-white smoke to make my eyes water. The truck’s acceleration was very poor. As the engine warmed up the problem disappeared which made it hard to diagnose. The GM dealer told me to go to the nearest Caterpillar dealer.

“The Caterpillar dealer replaced a thermostat, replaced fuel filters, and pressures were tested. I thought my problem was solved, but the worst was yet to come. A belly tarp was suggested by the factory and cardboard was put in front of the radiator. The mechanics rotated the air filter housing assembly to draw warmer air closer from the radiator. Numerous seemingly inconclusive tests were made to the engine. Another new thermostat was put in. The fuel injector was replaced and adjustments were made to the timing. Exhaust temperature tests were made. Cat wanted me to purchase, for $2,200, an exhaust brake to load the engine so I could maintain warmth to the engine in the city, for example.

“In my case, CAT made what I term ‘band aid’ solutions. I can accept that a company makes a lemon every so often. The difference is in how they handle the problems. My best experience with this truck was when I sold it last November.

“I was lucky, because this vehicle was not used as my primary source of income. I can’t help but think what would have happened if it had been a Caterpillar tractor or combine. Heaven help anyone with a $350,000 combine and a lemon engine.”

Caterpillar 3406 diesel engine

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Todd Heidemann, Willow, Alaska · Vol. 37, No. 5 (2013), p. 13

“My 1986 Ford F-150 pickup is equipped with a rebuilt 302 cu. in. gas engine and is always dependable, no matter what the weather.

“My 1994 Kenworth semi truck equipped with a new Caterpillar 3406 diesel engine does all the work of new trucks that cost 5 times as much. I keep up with a good synthetic grease and oil maintenance program.”

On the negative side, he lists his 2007 Ford F-450 pickup equipped with a Power Stroke diesel engine. “The engine is always blowing a gasket and it’s impossible to reach. This is a very over-engineered vehicle. The next time I have a shop truck built for my fleet I’ll recommend a Dodge diesel.”

Caterpillar 35 tractors

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Allan Brooks, Markesan, Wis. · Vol. 24, No. 5 (2000), p. 15

Allan’s happy with his two Caterpillar 35 tractors. One’s a 1997 model and the other a 1999 model. “The company engineers graciously designed and manufactured extra low disturbance belts for me. These low disturbance belts are available for purchase upon request to anyone. Compared to standard or other competitive belts, they reduce berming and compaction and also have better traction. We use the tractors on our reduced and no-till vegetable farm to do planting, drilling, and tillage work. It’s a shear pleasure to operate these efficient, productive tractors.”

Caterpillar 420D backhoe

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Terry Schwartz, Jamestown, N. Dak. · Vol. 46, No. 3 (2022), p. 12

“My Caterpillar 420D backhoe is built to last with exceptional lifting ability and, by using the outriggers and back boom, it’s the best hydraulic press I’ve ever owned for straightening out bent equipment.”

Caterpillar 45 row crop tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Austin Kruisselbrink, Woodstock, Minn. · Vol. 24, No. 6 (2000), p. 16

“My best buy is my 1998 Caterpillar 45 row crop tractor. It handles great in the field without compacting the soil and has a super smooth powershift transmission. It also provides great operator comfort for long working hours.”

Caterpillar 85D tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Francois Allard, St. Isidore, Alberta · Vol. 25, No. 6 (2001), p. 17

“Overall, I like my 1997 Caterpillar 85D tractor. However, in extremely wet conditions the tracks slip and lose steering. Basically, the tractor could use improved steering when it’s under load.”

Caterpillar 908 front-end loader equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Scott Freeman, Lucas, Ohio · Vol. 35, No. 3 (2011), p. 15

“We leased a 2005 Caterpillar 908 front-end loader equipped with a grapple bucket. Even though the Cat loader cost 2 to 3 times more than a skid loader, it can do 3 to 4 times more work. It articulates in the center and can turn short without wearing out the tires. It also has great lifting power and reach and is quick and smooth to operate.”

Caterpillar Challenger 35 Wide trac tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gerald and Ron Schneider, Troy, Kan. · Vol. 24, No. 6 (2000), p. 15

“Our 2000 Caterpillar Challenger 35 Wide Trac tractor is our best buy. We installed two Agri-Products poly saddle tanks inside the tracks with a total capacity of 520 gallons. The tanks are another best buy (Agri-Products, Inc., 1903 Division Ave., York, Neb. 68467 ph 800 288-1117). When we plant corn with the Challenger and our 12-row White 5100 planter, we put grass herbicides in the tanks and 10-34-0 fertilizer in a 400-gal., 3-pt. mounted tank. With this system we had a lot less compaction than when we used a front wheel assist tractor equipped with dual wheels and a 400-gal. tank. The compaction caused by the tracks goes straight down whereas the duals pack down and also out toward the rows.

“We had a 60-ft. Kuker spray boom on a 1,000-gal. trailer. We took the boom off and made a 3-pt. hitch for it that matches the quick hitch on the Challenger. In minutes we can have the spray boom hooked up and be ready to spray. We spray postemergence broadleaf weeds on the corn and Roundup on our drilled beans.

“We use the Challenger to cultivate and sidedress anhydrous ammonia on our corn. We use a 2000 Landoll 12-row cultivator equipped with a Navigator guidance hitch and a Micro-Trac anhydrous controller. They’re all best buys.

“We ordered the Challenger tracks with special application belts as we also use it to chop our alfalfa haylage and corn silage. These belts don’t tear up the ground whenever we turn at the end of the field. We also own a 1990 Cat Challenger 65. Tracks are the only way to go on our Missouri River bottomland.

“Another best buy are the B-33 Mole anhydrous ammonia knives we use on the cultivator (Hi-Pro Mfg., Box F, Rt. 24 West, Watseka, Ill. 60970 ph 815 432-5271). They look like they would pull hard. However, they pull easy. They seal by closing from the bottom up and are long wearing. It’s the best sealing knife I’ve ever used.”

On the “worst buy” side, “A couple of years ago we bought a 3-tool set of Texas Strippers wire strippers at a farm show. Two of them broke the first time we used them. They’re made in China.”

Caterpillar Challenger 65C tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Allan Brooks, MarKesan, Wis. · Vol. 21, No. 3 (1997), p. 15

Allan likes his 1995 Caterpillar Challenger 65C tractor. “The 30-in. heavy duty track treads very lightly on our soils and causes much less soil ‘berming’ on turns than deep lug tracks. It outperforms our beloved Steiger CP1325 tractor even though the Steiger has 40 more engine horsepower. “I’ve had problems with the 1996 May-Wes spiked poly closing wheels mounted on my row crop planter. The wheels worked well in drier soil conditions. However, in wet, sticky, heavy soils they completely balled up with dirt and didn’t close the furrow. I replaced them with cast iron wheels and they worked much better. I know that I wasn’t planting when the ground was too wet because the field produced my highest sweet corn yield.” Gale Shughart, Shughart Harvesting,

Caterpillar Challenger 75E

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Darrell Runge, Mason, Ill. · Vol. 28, No. 3 (2004), p. 15

“I’m well satisfied with my 1999 Caterpillar Challenger 75E. It rides good in the field with very little slippage when pulling large equipment. The engine has a lot of power and is fuel efficient, and the machine has a nice, roomy cab.”

Caterpillar Challenger 95E tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Lonnie Cellan, Inkom, Idaho · Vol. 25, No. 3 (2001), p. 14

“This tractor will pull one third more than my previous wheel tractors, and it uses less fuel doing it,” says Lonnie, pleased with his 1998 Caterpillar Challenger 95E tractor.

“My Raven 600 granular applicator controller is my worst buy. It blows fuses about every hour. When I called the company for help they couldn’t find anyone who knew if I could put a higher amp fuse in it. When I needed a magnet to go in a shaft sensor, it took two weeks and several calls to get it -and they wanted a $100 minimum order. I’ll never buy a product from this company again.”

Caterpillar Challenger Super 35 tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Jeff Merwin, Clarksburg, Calif. · Vol. 25, No. 3 (2001), p. 16

“We like our 1997 Caterpillar Challenger Super 35 tractor which we use to pull our Case-IH 4900 32-ft. Vibra Tiller field cultivator. The cultivator is also a best buy. We can get into the field a week earlier with tracks and, with the field cultivator, we can open 200 acres a day with virtually no compaction. The Challenger is comfortable to operate and quite fuel efficient.”

Caterpillar D2

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Terry Eyjolfson, Steep Rock, Manitoba · Vol. 20, No. 4 (1996), p. 15

A 1995 Deere 4600 MFD tractor equipped with a 460 front-end loader heads Terry’s “best buy” list. “It has a lot of hydraulic power which allows the loader to work fast. It also has a roomy cab and rides smooth. I really like the powershift transmission - it shifts smooth even at full throttle. The tractor had a few hydraulic problems but my dealer fixed them right away. It’s the best all-around tractor we’ve ever owned. However, the rear fenders could be improved. “My 1957 Caterpillar D2 is on its third set of rollers and chains but still works great. In the early years it had a problem with the dry clutch - after a hard push the clutch wouldn’t release. I solved the problem by sealing the bottom release shaft and pouring light oil into the clutch housing. No more problems with the clutch after 30 years.” On the minus side, he lists his Deere 3150 MFD tractor. “It bounced up and down the road like a rubber ball and was hard to shift on-the-go. It also had poor hydraulic pressure which caused the loader to work slow and it had a poor clutch. Despite all these problems it still had good trade-in value.”

Caterpillar D4 7U dozers

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Lyndon Jenkins, Freedom, Wyo. · Vol. 42, No. 3 (2018), p. 15

“Back in the 1980’s I bought two Caterpillar D4 7U dozers and two Deere tractors - an R and a 1956 70 diesel. All four machines are high quality and still in use today. I think the Deere R was, in its day, the best tractor Deere ever built.”

Caterpillar D4D

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
John Aaron Rissler, New Enterprise, Pa. · Vol. 24, No. 3 (2000), p. 14

John likes his 1970’s Caterpillar D4D, which he bought used in 1994 with 1,850 hours on it. “We bought it equipped with a 30-ft., 14,000-lb. center turret crane which we bought used from a steel yard. After removing the crane workings, we made a new hood and track covers and added a dash, turbocharger, and hydraulic pump to drive the transmission, which was originally shaft-driven. It makes a good farm tractor. We also installed a pto on it which we use to operate a silage blower. We’ve had the head off the engine once and planed it, then changed the valves to the kind that are used in turbocharged engines.”

Caterpillar D-6C 17 R

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Claude Pierret, Pasco, Wash. · Vol. 22, No. 6 (1998), p. 15

“Our best buy is the Caterpillar D-6C 17 R series tractor we purchased in 1974 with 200 hours,” says Claude. “The engine had 9,038 hours on it before it required an in-frame overhaul. The transmission, final drives, clutch lining and rear end gears have never been touched even though the tractor now has a total of 17,650 hours on it. It’s still used on a regular basis alongside a 1980 Cat D-6D we bought used five years ago.”

Caterpillar TracHoe lowboy

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
William Chisholm, Port Charlotte, Fla. · Vol. 45, No. 5 (2021), p. 15

“My best buys are my Caterpillar TracHoe, lowboy Globe trailer, and 2020 Peterbuilt. We liked the Cat TracHoe so much we bought 21 more along with buckets and claws. We’re in the demolition business and have 804 employees. Not bad for a good old farm boy. Caterpillar really treats us right. If I blow a hose, they pick it up and leave a new one full of fuel for us to use.”

Caterpillar skid loader equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Eli E. Mast, Jr., Camden, Wyo. · Vol. 34, No. 2 (2010), p. 14

“My Caterpillar skid loader equipped with rubber tracks is a versatile and powerful machine. I wouldn’t want to farm without it.”

Caterpillar mini excavator

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Don Cross, New Castle, Ind. · Vol. 39, No. 5 (2015), p. 13

“My 2010 Bobcat T870 skid loader had some problems, but the dealer promptly took care of them.

“My 2014 Caterpillar mini excavator has about 300 trouble-free hours on it. It’s an excellent machine.”

On the negative side, he lists 3 New Holland tractors, all bought new. “My T8010 model has a transmission fault on the computer screen that no one has been able to fix. The pto shaft literally fell out last fall while I was using the tractor on a grain cart.

“My T7.235 was delivered without working lights. I have to depress the brake pedals all the way to the floor before they’ll work, and if I press on them too hard they make a grinding noise that sounds like metal on metal. The company says this is normal.

“I’ve also had problems with my T5.115 equipped with a self-leveling front-end loader. I couldn’t control the electric-over-hydraulic pilot lever for the loader, which made it dangerous to use. Also, the air conditioner didn’t work. The dealer brought out a T4.95 so that I could mow roadsides. It had only 3 hrs. on it, but at 9 hrs. the pto went out. They ended up replacing the T5.115 with a new one, but it had the same loader and the same problems. The dealer doesn’t get any help from the company.

“Once New Holland gets your money, you’re on your own. I’ve contacted different people in the company, but no one seems to care about my problems. It’s the worst company I’ve ever dealt with. I don’t know how they stay in business.”

Caterpillar skidsteer

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Art Bargabos, Lynchburg, Va. · Vol. 28, No. 3 (2004), p. 13

“My 2002 Caterpillar skidsteer is a best buy. It’s easy to operate and well built.

“My 2004 Chevrolet 3500 1-ton dually extended cab pickup equipped with a Duramax diesel engine and Allison automatic transmission is a best buy. It has plenty of torque for pulling heavy loads.”

On the negative side, he lists his 1998 ASV MD-70 posi-track skid loader. “I started to have problems at 300 hours with the tracks falling off on hillsides, hydraulic lines breaking, and track bearings wearing out prematurely. It seemed like I was always working on the machine. It about bankrupted me. I got no support from the dealer or manufacturer.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW