Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Arctic Cat

Arctic Cat: what farmers say

29 reports in FARM SHOW · 20 Best Buys9 Worst Buys

Arctic Cat 500

1 Best Buy2 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Chris Schoenberger, Upper Sandusky, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 3 (2007), p. 15

“In September of 2006 I bought a 2007 Arctic Cat 500 ATV and have had nothing but problems with it. At 50 miles the actuator that puts the ATV in 4-WD failed. I took the machine back to the dealer to get it fixed under warranty. At 105 miles the right front axle drive went bad. Again, the dealer fixed it at no cost. At about 130 miles the ATV wouldn’t shift the way it should, so I brought it back to the dealer again.

“Last February I was riding with some friends, and as I was beginning to slow down, the front brakes locked up. The back of the 4-wheeler came over the top of me, pinning me to the ground. Luckily I was wearing a helmet. When I finally got out from under the 4-wheeler my friends rushed me to the hospital. After a few X-rays and tests they discovered that I had two broken bones in my right arm. Now I have a few plates and screws in the arm. I also had a deep cut in my chin which was caused by the helmet.

“The impact fractured my jaw and broke some of my teeth, and the doctors wired my jaw closed. I took the 4-wheeler back to the dealer and told them what had happened, and that I didn’t want this machine any more. They called the company which reimbursed me, and I used the money for hospital and doctor bills. Wearing a helmet saved my life.

“My 1998 Arctic Cat 500 is my best buy. I’ve never seen an old ATV work so hard. I use it to pull or haul 550 lbs. of feed, and tow it behind our farm equipment to the field so I have a way to get home. I also use it to haul milk to our calves. This ATV now has more than 3,600 miles on it, and I plan to hold onto it forever.”

Worst Buy
Ray Carson, Valley View, Texas · Vol. 30, No. 5 (2006), p. 14

“My Suzuki 700 Kingquad ATV equipped with electronic fuel injection is a best buy. It’s great to own an ATV that always starts. I never have to worry whether I’ll get back home.

“After owning two lemons in a row, an Arctic Cat 500 and a Kawasaki 650 Brute Force, it’s nice to have an ATV that I can depend on. I have to thank my dealer who, after working on and off for six weeks on the Kawasaki, allowed my full purchase price on another unit. Also, my thanks to the salesman who suggested I buy a Suzuki 700. I think I now have a machine that will provide many years of service.”

Worst Buy
David Cast, Beaver Crossing, Neb. · Vol. 28, No. 3 (2004), p. 12

A 2000 Arctic Cat 500 rates as David’s “worst buy.” “For the first 1 1/2 years it ran great, but then last year everything on it began to fail including CV boots, fuel gauge, belt, and clutch. Also, the block casting broke. No one is even willing to make an offer for a trade-in on this machine. I’ll never buy another Arctic Cat.”

Arctic Cat 500 ATV

1 Best Buy2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Chris Schoenberger, Upper Sandusky, Ohio · Vol. 31, No. 3 (2007), p. 15

“In September of 2006 I bought a 2007 Arctic Cat 500 ATV and have had nothing but problems with it. At 50 miles the actuator that puts the ATV in 4-WD failed. I took the machine back to the dealer to get it fixed under warranty. At 105 miles the right front axle drive went bad. Again, the dealer fixed it at no cost. At about 130 miles the ATV wouldn’t shift the way it should, so I brought it back to the dealer again.

“Last February I was riding with some friends, and as I was beginning to slow down, the front brakes locked up. The back of the 4-wheeler came over the top of me, pinning me to the ground. Luckily I was wearing a helmet. When I finally got out from under the 4-wheeler my friends rushed me to the hospital. After a few X-rays and tests they discovered that I had two broken bones in my right arm. Now I have a few plates and screws in the arm. I also had a deep cut in my chin which was caused by the helmet.

“The impact fractured my jaw and broke some of my teeth, and the doctors wired my jaw closed. I took the 4-wheeler back to the dealer and told them what had happened, and that I didn’t want this machine any more. They called the company which reimbursed me, and I used the money for hospital and doctor bills. Wearing a helmet saved my life.

“My 1998 Arctic Cat 500 is my best buy. I’ve never seen an old ATV work so hard. I use it to pull or haul 550 lbs. of feed, and tow it behind our farm equipment to the field so I have a way to get home. I also use it to haul milk to our calves. This ATV now has more than 3,600 miles on it, and I plan to hold onto it forever.”

Worst Buy
Ray Carson, Valley View, Texas · Vol. 30, No. 4 (2006), p. 14

“My worst buy was a new Arctic Cat 500 ATV. The first day I drove it two miles to check my cows and the exhaust nearly blistered my left leg. I solved the problem by adding a homemade aluminum shield.

“The ATV worked good for five months and about 400 miles, and then the spark plugs began to foul up every 25 to 30 miles. I took the ATV back to the dealer and asked them to fix this problem and also to fix the automatic choke, because it was becoming hard to start. The dealer replaced the spark plugs and charged me $37.50, and said that was all he could do because the warranty didn’t cover anything.

“The machine continued to go through spark plugs every 25 miles and was also hard to start and ran rough. My dealer wouldn’t help, so I took the ATV to a Kubota dealer with a reputation for excellent service. Their mechanic went through the machine and checked everything. He found that fuel was getting into the crankcase, but he couldn’t tell me why. I drove it only another 30 miles before it fouled up and quit. I drained the oil and found there was already a half pint of gas in the oil. I went back to my dealer who furnished another carburetor under warranty. But the new carburetor didn’t help, either, and gas continued to foul the spark plugs and get into the oil.

“Finally I had enough and traded the machine in. It cost me $300 per month to own this ATV for 14 months. I had owned two Kawasakis over the past 18 years and they were never in the shop, so I traded for a new Kawasaki 650 Brute Force model. I’m disappointed in it, too. It was in the shop twice during the first three weeks that I owned it. The dealer did his best to get it to run right, and the warranty has covered everything. They finally have it running good at high speeds now, but at low speeds the engine still coughs and smokes. I hope this machine isn’t another lemon. At least I have a dealer that tries and a warranty that pays off.”

Best Buy
William Manchalenko, St. Pierre Julys, Manitoba · Vol. 26, No. 1 (2002), p. 15

“I don’t know how I ever got along without it,” says William about his Arctic Cat 500 ATV. “I didn’t have an ATV until recently and now it’s the most valuable machine on my farm.

“For example, we use it to pull a side delivery wheel rake in the field. It’s great because it’s much softer on the field and does less damage to the alfalfa.

“We also use it with a pull-behind mower to cut ditches, which is a lot safer than using a tractor. We also pull a cart and wagons. It’s got tremendous power for all kinds of jobs.

“I made a cart out of scrap material which I use to haul the ATV behind a pickup, and then I pull the cart with the ATV to do work.

“We’ve been doing so much around the farm with this machine that all my neighbors are watching me to see what we do next.”

Arctic Cat 500 4-WD ATV

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Phil Ruble, Nebo, Ill. · Vol. 38, No. 2 (2014), p. 15

“Our 2004 Arctic Cat 500 4-WD ATV was my dad’s primary farm vehicle until he passed away in June 2012. It has almost 14,000 miles on it now but has required only minor repairs. We do all the regular maintenance and use Arctic Cat synthetic oil. I only wish it had a brake on the handlebar.”

Best Buy
Chris Schoenberger, Upper Sandusky, Ohio · Vol. 23, No. 1 (1999), p. 15

“My best buy is my 1998 Arctic Cat 500 4-WD ATV. It can pull a full wagon and can even pull a Deere header trailer loaded with a 924 head. It runs good and fast. My only complaint is that the 4.25 gal. fuel tank is too small.”

Arctic Cat ATV

0 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Don Best, Blanket, Texas · Vol. 37, No. 2 (2013), p. 14

Don’s “worst buy” is his 2003 Arctic Cat 250cc ATV. “The first few years after I bought it, I didn’t use it much because it took so long to start and to warm up before I could use it. Then a few years ago I started using it more, and one day in the middle of a dry pasture it started smoking on front where the wiring harness goes through a metal clip to the controls on the handlebars. The machine almost caught fire before I could disconnect the battery.

“I loaded the ATV up and took it to my shop. After checking it out, it was clear the wiring had shorted out where a metal clip holder rubbed against it. I also discovered the wires were all black-taped together with no other protection. I looked at other ATV brands and the wires on them weren’t taped together, but instead had heavy insulation and protection and the part holding the wires was also insulated.

“I called both the dealer and the corporate office, but they weren’t interested in hearing what happened, nor were they willing to give me a replacement wiring harness, even though this was clearly a factory defect because when the wires shorted out, they caught on fire and melted the insulation and wires together. After several hours I was able to rewire everything properly.

“I can’t believe a company this large would tape the wires together. And then to have a metal contact on the clip holding the wires? It was just a matter of time until it shorted out, because the wires flex and pull as you steer and turn from side to side.”

Worst Buy
Stanley Price, Valleyview, Alberta · Vol. 33, No. 3 (2009), p. 14

Stanley likes his 2006 GM Canyon truck. “It has plenty of power to pass vehicles and to climb hills. We use it hard on our farm for hauling and towing, and it has survived our rough roads.

“My 2008 Arctic Cat ATV is made of cheap plastic, and one time while I was chasing cows the lights fell out.”

Arctic Cat snowmobiles

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Murray Jantzi, Warren, Ontario · Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997), p. 14

Murray says he likes his Arctic Cat snowmobiles but has trouble getting parts for them. “I have no complaints about the snowmobiles themselves. They’re excellent. Mine had more than 7,000 miles on it before it needed any major repairs. Two winters ago the primary clutch needed repairs and I had to wait more than four weeks for parts. Last winter the engine had to be repaired and I waited five weeks to get it back. I was told that parts had been shipped, but they never arrived.

“Arctic Cat products are excellent. But what good is their product if they can’t supply parts?”

Best Buy
Ken Loewenhagen, Hortonville, Wis. · Vol. 21, No. 3 (1997), p. 14

“I’ve owned Arctic Cat snowmobiles for 27 years, but I seriously doubt whether I’ll ever buy another one. Last October my wife bought a new ZR 580 electronic fuel-injected snowmobile and also a new ZL 440 model. We used them for the first time during a week-long vacation up north. The first time we started the 580 we had problems with a scoured piston. That was just the beginning. By the time the snowmobiles had 1,000 miles on them, I had put more than 600 miles on my truck driving back and forth to the dealer who’s only 20 miles away. The dealer did all he could to help. My complaint is with the company itself. I sent five different letters to them, but the only response was a form letter saying they were sorry and that they would contact the dealer to see why we were having problems. “I called the company and was told that a service manager would contact me the next day. That was two months ago and I haven’t heard anything even though the dealer contacted the company three times asking them to call me. Another problem is that five months after buying the machines we still don’t have a warranty card. The dealer told the company about the problem and I mentioned it in all of my letters as well as during my phone call. I’m a very patient person, but this is ridiculous. I guess it’s time to change brands. I feel sorry for the company’s dealers. It’s no fun trying to deal with companies that aren’t customer oriented. I know this because I’m a service manager for an equipment dealer. When we have this kind of problem we stop selling the product.”

Arctic Cat (general)

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Kyle Carrigan, Corsicana, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 4 (2008), p. 13

“I researched a lot of different 4-wheelers before I bought my 2006 Arctic Cat, and I’m glad I did. It’s my best buy. At the time it was the only ATV that offered true 4-WD, plus the overall rating on chassis and ground clearance was at the top of its class. In my opinion, if you buy a Honda, Yamaha, or Kawasaki you’re only paying for the name.”

Arctic Cat 2-WD ATV equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Jay C. Reiner, Stewart, Minn. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 15

“My 2006 Arctic Cat 2-WD ATV equipped with a 250 cc engine is my best buy. It has plenty of power and it’s a joy to ride. Great for either work or play.”

On the minus side, he lists his 2005 A-Maize-ing Heat corn burning furnace. “The dealer told me this furnace could burn corn, wood pellets, or even cherry pits. However, the first time I tried it - using all wood pellets - the auger motor burned out at a cost of $100. The outside temperature was 10 degrees below zero so I had to hand feed the stove every hour or so just to keep our house warm. The dealer said I should mix the pellets with corn instead of using just pellets. I wish he would have told me that sooner. Another problem is the stove doesn’t work properly whenever the outside temperature is above 30 degrees. It can be 78 degrees inside the house yet the furnace will still kick in even though no heat is needed. It uses about 50 lbs. of corn per day.

“Another problem is the dealer doesn’t know any more about how the furnace works than I did when I bought it. I’ve called the company several times but get only a recording, and my calls are never returned. The company needs to make this furnace easier to light. At times I had to use a whole $7 bottle of starter gel, yet still couldn’t get the furnace going. It’s cheaper to just keep it going and waste one bushel of corn than to hassle with trying to start it up every day. I’d never buy another one and don’t recommend them to anyone.”

Arctic Cat 300 4-WD ATV

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Haskell W. Carr, Twin Falls, Idaho · Vol. 30, No. 2 (2006), p. 14

“I like my 2003 Arctic Cat 300 4-WD ATV. It has a super low range that is really handy when I use the machine to pull my 15-gal. sprayer. This model rides and handles better than our other 1991 ATV. However, I wish it had a cruise control so I could keep a steady speed for spraying.”

On the “worst buy” side, “The power steering failed on our 2002 Buick LeSabre with only about 33,000 miles on it, but the 36-month warranty had expired three months earlier and the company wouldn’t honor it. I had to pay $700 out of my pocket.”

Arctic Cat 300 4-wheeler

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Carol Perrer, Columbia, Miss. · Vol. 32, No. 4 (2008), p. 12

“My Arctic Cat 300 4-wheeler is a handy work horse. I use it to pull fencing, to spray trees and fields, and to do general chores. It saves gas.”

Arctic Cat 366 ATV

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Wayne Gadow, Colville, Wash. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

“I use my 2010 Arctic Cat 366 ATV to plow snow off my 1/4-mile driveway. It works a lot faster than my Branson 3510 tractor, although that has been a great small farm tractor. The Arctic Cat has a lot of power and traction so I haven’t had to use tire chains. This machine purrs like a kitten in the dairy section of a grocery store.”

Arctic Cat 400 4-WD ATV

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Doug Alberts, Melville, Sask. · Vol. 29, No. 6 (2005), p. 15

Doug’s the satisfied owner of a 2003 Arctic Cat 400 4-WD ATV. “It has a good suspension system, a good engine, and a lot of clearance. So far we have 3,500 trouble-free miles on it.”

Arctic Cat 400 ATV equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gerald H. Covell, Lombardy, Ontario · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“It has exceeded all my expectations,” says Gerald about his 2005 Arctic Cat 400 ATV equipped with an automatic transmission, locking differential, and 2 or 4-WD. “It has enough power to perform all our chores, and more. I use it with a blade to clean out my horse stalls and paddock. No problems.”

Arctic Cat 400 TBX ATV

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Andy Fiehler, Lawrenceburg, Ky. · Vol. 35, No. 1 (2011), p. 13

“In 2006 I bought an Arctic Cat 400 TBX ATV. When we bought our farm a few years ago I thought about buying both a tractor and an ATV. But when I found a tow-behind, self-powered bush hog mower, I decided to spend the money on just an ATV and not on a tractor. And when I found the Arctic Cat TBX I knew I’d found the right ATV.

“While the TBX has handlebars like an ATV, it has a dump bed like a utility vehicle. It has plenty of power to tow the bush hog or a trailer full of gravel, hay or firewood, or even a deer. And, I can go 4-wheeling when I get my chores done. It’s a great machine for both work and fun. With the machine’s storage compartments, I always have the tools I need, and with the big 6-gal. fuel tank I never run out of gas.”

Arctic Cat 454 2-WD ATV

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Tom Hampton, Litchfield, Ill. · Vol. 23, No. 5 (1999), p. 16

“So far we’ve been completely satisfied with our 1997 Arctic Cat 454 2-WD ATV. The company engineers really did their homework on this product. The gearing on the transmission is about right for most jobs, but the ride is the best selling point – it doesn’t bounce you all over when you’re crossing fields or ditches in high gear. I use the machine for hunting, fishing, recreation, scouting crops, and moving empty gravity flow wagons between fields. It has more than enough power for any job on our farm. We’ve even used it to pull-start our small 40 hp tractor. W also have a 4-WD ATV from another company that can’t even move the tractor.”

Arctic Cat 454 4-WD ATV

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
John Carson, Sherwood Park, Alberta · Vol. 28, No. 2 (2004), p. 14

“My 1998 Arctic Cat 454 4-WD ATV is my worst buy. I had to take it back to the shop five times before it even had 350 miles on it. The only things that worked correctly on it were the tires. I had to take it back to the garage five different times before it even had 500 miles on it. One problem was that it wouldn’t start - I had to manually prime it. The tie rods broke due to bad welds. Overall, this machine was poorly designed, with the weight way too far forward. As a result, one time I got it stuck almost down to the handlebars on some wet land where I was able to drive right through with other ATV’s. I still have this machine because I wouldn’t want to sell it to anyone.”

Arctic Cat 454 4-wheeler ATV

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Tom Brozik, Fairfax, Minn. · Vol. 23, No. 6 (1999), p. 15

“My 1998 Arctic Cat 454 4-wheeler ATV does everything I ask of it. I use it to pick up rocks, spray crops, pull wagons and other jobs. I highly recommend it.”

On the negative side, he lists his 1996 Case-IH 4800 Vibra Shank field cultivator. “Soon after I bought it the ends on the spring holders started to bend and break off. I got a call from the dealer saying that the company would replace my holders with heavier ones for $700. I declined the offer. For 35 years I had used Deere field cultivators and never had any problems like this. I guess we’re all entitled to one mistake.”

Arctic Cat 454 Bearcat ATV

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Doug Reich, Versailles, Ill. · Vol. 26, No. 5 (2002), p. 14

“All of our Deere tractors have been best buys, including a 4450, 4430, 8100, 4020, 2640, and 5520. All of them are easy to operate and reliable, strong performers. The people who designed these tractors put a lot of thought into what they were doing.

“My 1997 Arctic Cat 454 Bearcat ATV is my worst buy. It has had numerous electrical problems and has already gone through seven bal joints. The CV boots split within the first year, and the front end started chattering after only about 18 months. Also, the machine went through a lot of spark plugs, the fan motor burned up, a brake cable locked up, and the gear shifter splines wore out. Resale is terrible”.

“My International Harvester 585 has been a reliable tractor but you tend to forget that after you sit on it awhile because of the lousy ergonomics. Also, this tractor is terribly underpowered.”

Arctic Cat 4-WD ATV equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Kyle Carrigan, Corsicana, Texas · Vol. 32, No. 3 (2008), p. 13

Kyle’s happy with his 2006 Arctic Cat 4-WD ATV equipped with an automatic transmission. “I looked at a lot of different makes of 4-wheelers before I bought my Arctic Cat. It was the only one at the time that offered true 4-WD, and its overall rating for the chassis and ground clearance was at the top of its class. Anyone can buy a Honda, Yamaha, or Kawasaki, but if they do they’re paying extra for the name.”

Arctic Cat 700 EFI 4-wheeler almost every day

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Harvey Robertson, Kingman, Ariz. · Vol. 43, No. 3 (2019), p. 14

“I ride my 2000 Arctic Cat 700 EFI 4-wheeler almost every day. I love it.

“My 2018 Textron Off-Road Havoc X ATV is a real lemon. Within the first 9 mos. it was in the shop more than 100 days. I paid about $19,000 for this machine, so it should have been in perfect condition when new. Now I can’t even sell it because I won’t screw someone on purpose.”

Arctic Cat DVX 250 4-wheeler

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Ryan Solberg, Goodridge, Minn. · Vol. 47, No. 4 (2023), p. 14

“The power steering and hydraulic deck lift on my Deere X540 lawn mower work great. Lets me give my yard a golf course finish.”

Ryan isn’t pleased with his Arctic Cat DVX 250 4-wheeler. “The design is poor, and it has a lot of transmission problems. It doesn’t stand up well at all. Arctic Cat needs to develop pride in their products again.”

Arctic Cat Prowler 700 cc

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gary Thompson, Preston, Mo. · Vol. 32, No. 4 (2008), p. 14

“Our 2007 Volkswagen Rabbit rides like a Cadillac, runs great, and gets about 30 mpg. It has more than 30,000 miles on it. I’m 6 ft. tall and weigh 300 lbs. so I really appreciate that this car has more room in the front seat than my 2001 Dodge full-size 1/2-ton pickup. No problems.

“Our worst buy was our 2007 Polaris XP side-by-side 4-wheeler ATV equipped with a 700 cc engine. It rode and ran great but required a lot of expensive repairs. In less than six months we had to replace drive belts three different times at a cost of $180 apiece. About six months ago we got smart and traded it for a 2008 Arctic Cat Prowler 700 cc side by side ATV. We never replaced a single belt.”

Arctic Cat ZR 600 snowmobile

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Michael Boeddeker, Waseca, Minn. · Vol. 44, No. 4 (2020), p. 14

Michael likes his 2000 Arctic Cat ZR 600 snowmobile. “I’m 53 years old and enjoy the older-style snowmobiles. This one is fast, easy to start and handle, and rides great. Best of all, it’s paid for.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 2011 Ford F-150 pickup equipped with a V-6 engine. “I previously owned an F-350 Lariat equipped with a diesel engine, but it got totaled out in an accident. Compared to the F-350, the F-150 is more like driving a car because you sit lower to the ground. Also, it has poor fuel economy for a V-6 at just 15.2 mpg. Now it’s rusting bad, and taking care of that problem would cost about $3,000. The transmission is acting up, too.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW